The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About07-09-02 packetCity of Saratoga HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES Date: Tuesday, July 9, 2002 9:00 a.m. Place: City Hall Planning Conference Room, 13777 Fruitvale Avenue Type: Regular Meeting Welcome Aboard Patricia, Tom, and Paul I. Routine Organization A. Roll Call: PRESENT - Bailey, Ballingall, Conrado, Grens, Koepernik, Lowdermilk, and Peck ABSENT - NONE GUESTS - Stan Bogosian, Danielle Surdin B. Approval of minutes from 6/11/02 - Approved 7 -0 C. Posting of the Agenda - Pursuant to Government Code Section 54954.2, the agenda was posted on Wednesday July 3, 2002 D. Oral Communications - Discussed park and recreation survey and improving the city web site. E. Written Communications - None II. Old Business A. Update on the Orchard adopt a tree kiosk - Updated by Norm Koepernik. B. Heritage Tours - Continue discussion and looked at brochures from other cities. C. Create calendar of old historic photos - Reviewed progress. D. Austin Way- Heritage Lane designation - Reviewed Staff Report recommending the designation to the Planning Commission. E. Heritage Orchard update and discussion - Discussed the existing signage for the orchard. III. New Business Please bring your e -mail address - Collected addresses from all of the members. IV. Items Initiated by the Commission Review Heritage Preservation Ordinance - Discussed existing ordinance. V. Items Initiated by the Secretary Update Heritage Resource Inventory - Discussed project. Map Historic Resources - Discussed goals of mapping sites using a GIS system that could include photos of all of the sites. VI. Adjournment 9:00 a.m. Tuesday August 13, 2002 - Planning Division Conference Room City of Saratoga HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA Date: Tuesday, July 9, 2002 9:00 a.m. Place: City Hall Planning Conference Room, 13777 Fruitvale Avenue Type: Regular Meeting Welcome Aboard Patricia, Tom, and Paul I. Routine Organization A. Roll Call B. Approval of minutes from 6/11/02 C. Posting of the Agenda - Pursuant to Government Code Section 54954.2, the agenda was posted on Wednesday July 3, 2002 D. Oral Communications E. Written Communications II. Old Business A. Update on the Orchard adopt a tree kiosk B. Heritage Tours - Continue discussion C. Create calendar of old historic photos D. Austin Way- Heritage Lane designation E. Heritage Orchard update and discussion III. New Business Please bring your e-mail address IV. Items Initiated by the Commission Review Heritage Preservation Ordinance V. Items Initiated by the Secretary Update Heritage Resource Inventory Map Historic Resources VI. Adjournment 9:00 a.m. Tuesday August 13, 2002 - Planning Division Conference Room City of Saratoga HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES Date: Tuesday, June 11, 2002 9:00 a.m. Place: Warner Hutton House, 13777 Fruitvale Avenue Type: Regular Meeting I. Routine Organization A. Roll Call: PRESENT- Koepernik, Ballingall, Grens, Peck ABSENT -None GUESTS -Tom Lowdermilk, Patricia A. Bailey, Jill Hunter, Danielle Surdin B. Approval of minutes from 5/14/02-Approved 4 -0 C. Posting of the Agenda - Pursuant to Government Code Section 54954.2, the agenda was posted on Thursday June 6, 2002 D. Oral Communications - Willys Peck asked staff for clarification on the moving of the Senior Center to its new site. Danielle Surdin gave a brief update on the project. Jill Hunter asked about the status of some of the downtown historic structures that are deteriorating. Danielle Surdin gave a brief update on some of the potential projects she has had contact with concerning the various sites. Tom Lowdermilk discussed the possibility of updating the Web site on historic structures. E. Written Communications II. Old Business A. Update on the Orchard adopt a tree kiosk -Norm Koepernik updated the HPC on the progress and noted that he is currently working on the cost estimates for the project. B. Heritage Tours - Continue discussion - Danielle Surdin is working on the Historic Walking Tour. C. Create calendar of old historic photos -Work is continuing on the calendar. Danielle Surdin gave a short presentation on the various price options and materials available for the calendar. D. Austin Way- Heritage Lane designation -Staff gave a brief update on the project. E. Heritage Orchard updates and discussion -Staff explained what happened at the City Council meeting and gave a brief update on the project. III. New Business A. Review plans for a new 590 sq. ft detached two -car garage at 21120 Wardell Road. The property is listed as a local Heritage Resource. Staff will provide plans and a presentation at the meeting. Project Approved 4 -0 IV. Items Initiated by the Commission Review Heritage Preservation Ordinance V. Items Initiated by the Secretary July and August meetings will need to be in the Planning Departments meeting room due to Kids Camp in the Warner Hutton House. VI. Adjournment 9:00 a.m. Tuesday July 9, 2002 - Planning Division Conference Room Updated: 6/88, 11/90, 7/91, 4/93, 4/98, 5/99, 3/00 City of Saratoga Exhibit A 1 HERITAGE RESOURCES INVENTORY Original HPC Resolution/ Address Historic or Common Name Architectural Stvle Criteria # CC Ordinance 1 1 HP -88 -01 13361 Argonne Dr. Johnson -Kerr House (c. 1900) Craftsman a,c 2 2 HP -88 -01 20021 Bella Vista Rancho Bella Vista ( 1917) Italian Villa a,b,c,d 3 3 HP -88 -01 14413 -14415 Big Kerr Building/Hogg Building False -front a,b,e Basin Way (1910) 4* 4 HP -88 -01 14421 Big Basin Wy. Saratoga Bank Building (1913) Classic Revival a,c,e HP -18 5 5 HP -88 -01 14495 Big Basin Wy. Hutchinson Building (18 84) Pioneer a,e 6 6 HP -88 -01 14501 -14503 Big Cloud -Smith Building (1884, Decorative Pioneer/ a,b,e Basin Way 1896) Neo Classical 7 7 HP -88 -01 14510 -14540 Big J.E. Foster House (c. 1882) Pioneer Cottage a,e Basin Way 8 8 HP -88 -01 14519 Big Basin Wy. Green Store Building (c. 1890) False -front Pioneer a,e 9 9 HP -88 -01 14521 Big Basin Wy. Grover House (c. 1895) Pioneer Cottage a,e 10 10 HP -88 -01 14605 Big Basin Wy. Pettis Livery (c. 1898) Pioneer a,c,e 11 11 HP -88 -01 14605 Big Basin Wy. Erwin T. King House (c. 1875) Colonial/Salt Box a,b,c,e 12 12 HP -88 -01 14630 Big Basin Wy. John Henry House (18 69) Pioneer Cottage a,b,e 13 13 HP -88 -01 14669 Big Basin Wy. Fabretti House (1881) Pioneer Cottage a,e 14 14 HP -88 -01 20900 Big Basin Wy. Maclay Cottage (c. 1890) Queen Anne a,c 15 15 HP -88 -01 21000 Big Basin Wy. Hakone Gardens (1917 -1918) Japanese a,c,d,e,g 16 16 HP -88 -01 20150 Bonnie Brae James Richards House (c. 19 10) Craftsman Bungalow a,b,c 17 17 HP -88 -01 20601 Brookwood F.B. Willard House (1916) California Craftsman a,c Lane 18 18 HP -88 -01 20611 Brookwood Henry Jarboe House (1858) Pioneer a Lane 19 ** 19 HP -88 -01 19474 Burgundy Cherrymount (origins 1860) Farmhouse a,f Way 1 2 Original HPC Resolution/ Address Historic or Common Name Architectural Style Criteria # CC Ordinance 20 HP -99 -01 19050 Camino Barco Colonel Barco Residence (1925) Pioneer Farmhouse c, e 21 20 HP -88 -01 19161 Cox Avenue Joseph Cox House (1915) Craftsman a,b,c 22 21 HP -88 -01 14445 Donna Lane Webster -Sutro House (1916) Dutch Colonial a,c 23 22 HP -88 -01 14315 Douglass Lane Hayfield Caretaker/ English Country a,c,d Garage Buildings (1920) 24 23 HP -88 -01 19855 Douglass Ln. Crowell House (c. 1880's) Pioneer a,c 25* 24 HP -88 -01 Fruitvale /Saratoga Central Park Orchard n/a a,g HP -3 Ave. 26 25 HP -88 -01 13616 Fruitvale Ave. Reynolds Ranch (c.1870) Pioneer a,b,g 27 26 HP -88 -01 14251 Fruitvale Ave. Novakovich Ranch (c. 1890) Queen Anne a,c,g 28 27 HP -88 -01 14500 Fruitvale Ave. Odd Fellows Home Mission Revival a,b,c,d (1912) 29 HP -91 -01 14625 Fruitvale Ave. Saso Herb Gardens (1906 -1910) Craftsman a,g 30 28 HP -88 -01 14711 Fruitvale Ave. Ellis House (1885) Folk Victorian a,e 31 HP -91 -01 14901 Fruitvale Ave. Sunshine Williams (pre 1900) Pioneer Cottage a,b 32 29 HP -88 -01 15095 Fruitvale Ave. Fair Oaks (1905) Prairie /Classic Revival a,b,c 33 30 HP -88 -01 19490 Glen Una Dr. Carter House (1925) Spanish Colonial a,c 34 HP -99 -02 20201 Hill Avenue Frederick Wessels Residence 1920's Eclectic c,e (1926) 35 31 HP -88 -01 20252 Hill Avenue La Mirada - Hale Estate (1930) Mediterranean a,b 36 32 HP -88 -01 20235 La Paloma Hayfield House (1920 -1921) English Country a,c,d Av. 37 HP -91 -01 20250 La Paloma Fontaine or Heid Residence Tudor/Normandy b,e Av. (1924) 38 HP -97 -02 20271 La Paloma Un -named (1916) Craftsman c,d Av. 39 33 HP -88 -01 20600 Lomita Hannah McCarty House Pioneer /Greek Revival a,b,c HP -16 Avenue (c. 1890) 40 HP -91 -01 Madrone Hill Road Madrone Hill - Scannavino Mediterranean Gardens c,g Residence 41 HP -91 -01 20570 Marion Road Stamper House (1892) Pioneer Cottage a,c 42 34 HP -88 -01 20731 Marion Road Pollard House (c. 1892) Queen Anne a,b 43 HP -91 -01 18500 Marshall Lane Bellicitti Ranch (c. 1870) Pioneer a,c,e,f,g 2 3 oripi„al HPC Resolution/ Address Historic or Common Name Architectural Style Criteria # CC Ordinance 44 35 HP -88 -01 20271 Merrick Drive Rev. Pollard Ranch House Pioneer a,b (c. 1880) 45* 36 HP -88 -01 15400 Montalvo Villa Montalvo (1912) Italian Villa a,b,c,d HP -2 Road 46* 37 HP -88 -01 14475 Oak Place Almond Hill (1910 -1912) Shingle Craftsman a,b HP -23 47* 38 HP -88 -01 14410 Oak Street Village Library (1927) Mission Revival a,b,c HP -9 48* 39 HP -88 -01 14488 Oak Street Saratoga Volunteer Fire Bell n/a a,b HP -12 (1903) 49 HP -91 -01 14524 Oak Street Hanchett House (c. 1886) Pioneer Cottage c,e 50 40 HP -88 -01 14534 Oak Street Lundblad's Lodge (1905) Craftsman Shingle a,c,e 51 41 HP -88 -01 14592 Oak Street Saratoga Grammar School Spanish Colonial a,e,f (1923 -1924) Revivial 52 42 HP -88 -01 14666 Oak Street Congregational Church Pioneer /Greek Revival a,b Parsonage (c. 1886) 53* 43 HP -88 -01 14672 Oak Street William King House (c. 1877) Pioneer /Colonial a,b HP -5 Revival 54* 44 HP -88 -01 14683 Oak Street Missionary Settlement House Queen Anne a,b,c,e HP -13 (c.1897) 55 45 HP -88 -01 14690 Oak Street Van Arsdale House (c. 1900) Queen Anne a,c 56 HP -91 -01 14701 Oak Street Hainich Residence (c. 1900) Pioneer Cottage e,g 57 HP -91 -01 14739 Oak Street Hayes House (c. 1906) Pioneer Cottage e,g 58 46 HP -88 -01 14766 Oak Street Madronia Cemetery (c. 1850) n/a a,b,g 59 47 HP -88 -01 20390 Park Place Saratoga Federated Church Mission Revival a,b,c,d,e (1923 w /add) 60 HP -97 -01 20391 Park Place Winslow House (1920) Craftsman b,d,g 61* 48 HP -88 -01 20399 Park Place Saratoga Foothill Club (1915- Bay Region/Craftsman a,b,c,d,e HP -1 1916) 62 49 HP -88 -01 15320 Peach Hill Carey House (1929) Monterey Colonial a,c,d Road 63 50 HP -88 -01 14574 Pierce Road Paul Masson Lodge (1936) French Chateau a,b,c 64 HP -91 -01 13089 Quito Road Mitchell Residence (1909) Craftsman a,c,f,g 65 HP -91 -01 13939 Quito Road Brandenburg House (1890) Colonial Revival a,c 66* 51 HP -88 -01 15231 Quito Road Casa Tierra (1941 -1943) Southwest a,b,c HP -14 3 Original HPC Resolution/ Address Historic or Common Name Architectural Stvle Criteria # CC Ordinance 67 52 HP -88 -01 20105 Rancho Bella Sterne - Andres House (c. 1880's) Pioneer /Classic Revival a,c Vista 68* 53 HP -88 -01 18490 Ravenwood Brandenburg House (1888) Decorative Pioneer a,c HP -15 Dr. 69 HP -19 Saratoga Avenue Heritage Lane n/a a,e,f,g (Fruitvale to Hwy. 9) 70 HP -91 -01 13150 Saratoga Ave. Jose Moya Del Pino Mosaic n/a a,d (1959) 71 54 HP -88 -01 13631 Saratoga Ave. Rawdon Dell Ranch (1916) California Bungalow a,c 72 HP -91 -01 13741 Saratoga Ave. Rowen House (c. 1903) Craftsman c,e,f 73 ** HP -91 -01 13850 Saratoga Ave. Professor Fred Smith Residence California Bungalow a,e (c. 19 10) 74 HP -91 -01 13855 Saratoga Ave. Lanphear House (c. 19 10) Craftsman c,e 75 55 HP -88 -01 13915 Saratoga Ave. McGrew- Atkinson House (1880) Pioneer a,c 76 HP -91 -01 13935 Saratoga Ave. Great Lakes Nursery (c. 1904) Bungalow a,e 77 56 HP -88 -01 13991 Saratoga Ave. Meason House (c. 1880's) Pioneer a,c 78 HP -91 -01 14024 Saratoga Ave. Dr. Hogg Residence (1905) b,c 79* HP -91 -01 14065 Saratoga Ave. Florence Cunningham Residence Craftsman Bungalow b,c,e HP -20 (c. 1930) 80 57 HP -88 -01 14075 Saratoga Ave. E.M. Cunningham House (1882) Decorative Pioneer a,b,c,e 81 58 HP -88 -01 14120 Saratoga Ave. J.C. Cunningham House (1889) Decorative Pioneer a,b 82 59 HP -88 -01 14189 Saratoga Ave. Thorny House (c. 1870) Pioneer a,c 83 HP -91 -01 14199 Saratoga Ave. Four Pines (c. 1890) Pioneer Bungalow c,e 84 60 HP -88 -01 14275 Saratoga Ave. Higinbotham House (1920) California Craftsman a,c 85 61 HP -88 -01 14280 Saratoga Ave. Luther Cunningham Stone Period Revival a,b,c,e House (1924 -1926) 86 62 HP -88 -01 14300 Saratoga Ave. Francis Dresser House (1870) Neoclassic a,c 87 HP -91 -01 20851 Saratoga Hills Nelson Gardens /Shumer n/a e,g Ranch/Shady Oaks Glen (c. 1880's) 88 HP -91 -01 21060 Saratoga Hills Bonney- Abernathy House Craftsman a,c (c. 1913 -1920) 89 63 HP -88 -01 Saratoga -Los Gatos Memorial Arch and Landmark Spanish Colonial a,b,c,d,e Rd./ Saratoga Ave. Plaque (1919) Revival 4 5 Original HPC Resolution/ Address Historic or Common Name Architectural Style Criteria # CC Ordinance 90 HP -91 -01 19220 Saratoga -Los Spinaza Ranch (c. 1890) Craftsman Shingle c,f Gatos Road 91 64 HP -88 -01 19221 Saratoga -Los Tibbett House (19 10) Craftsman Bungalow a,c Gatos Road 92 HP -91 -01 20280 Saratoga -Los Seven Oaks (c. 1920) Mediterranean c,e Gatos Road w /Craftsman details 93* 65 HP -88 -01 20330 Saratoga -Los The Deodars (1912) Mediterranean Villa a,c HP -17 Gatos Road 94 66 HP -88 -01 20360 Saratoga -Los Bellgrove (1904) Spanish Colonial a,c Gatos Road 95 67 HP -88 -01 20375 Saratoga -Los Woodleigh (1911) Greek Revival a,c,e Gatos Road 96 68 HP -88 -01 20400 Saratoga -Los T.S. Montgomery Stone Wall (c. n/a a,b,d Gatos Road 1913) 97* 69 HP -88 -01 20450 Saratoga -Los Saratoga Historical Museum False -front Pioneer a,c,e HP -7 Gatos Road (c. 1904 -1905) 98* 70 HP -88 -01 20460 Saratoga -Los McWlliams House (1850's) Pioneer Cottage a,c,e HP -10 Gatos Road 99 71 HP -88 -01 20490 Saratoga -Los Methodist - Episcopal Church Pioneer a,b,e Gatos Road (1896) 100 HP -92 -01 12795 Saratoga- Miller House (1909 -1911) Craftsman a,c,f Sunnyvale Road 101* 72 HP -88 -01 14051 Saratoga- Neil Carmichael House (1914) Neoclassic a,b HP -22 Sunnyvale Road 102 73 HP -88 -01 14421 Saratoga- B. Grant Taylor House (c. 1906- California Craftsman a.b,c,d Sunnyvale Road 1907) 103* 74 HP -88 -01 14650 Sixth Street Nardie House (c. 1895) Queen Anne a,c HP -11 104 75 HP -88 -01 14700 Sixth Street St. John's Episcopal Church (c. Pioneer a,b 1896) 105* 76 HP -88 -01 13495 Sousa Lane Warner Hutton House (c. 1896) Queen Anne a,c HP -21 Moved to: 13777 Fruitvale Ave. 106 77 HP -88 -01 20640 Third Street Sam Cloud Hay & Feed Pioneer a,b,c,e Warehouse (c.1890) 107 78 HP -88 -01 12239 Titus Avenue Andersen House (c. late 1880's) Pioneer a,c 108 HP -98 -01 19101 Via Tesoro El Tesoro - Dr. Clemmer Peck Adobe b,c,e Court Residence (1935 & 1967) 109 79 HP -88 -01 11995 Walbrook Dr. Hyde House (1895) Craftsman Bungalow a,c HP -24 5 Oricinal HPC Resolution/ # CC Ordinance 110 HP -91 -01 111 80 HP -88 -01 Address Historic or Common Name 21120 Wardell Road Anna Bee House (c. 1902) 20770 Wildwood Springer House (c. 1851) Wy. Architectural Style Criteria Traditional "Pyramid" c,e or Princess Anne Pioneer a,b * Properties marked with an asterisk are also Designated Heritage Landmarks. * *Fonner Historic Site indicates a structure of historic significance which was demolished and no longer exists. Documentation of the site historical background is kept in the City's files. SELECTION CRITERIA a) The property exemplifies or reflects special elements of the cultural, social, economic, political, aesthetic, engineering or architectural history of the City, the County, the State or the nation; or b) The property is identified with persons or events significant in local, county, state or national history; or c) The property embodies distinctive characteristics of a style, type, period or method of construction, or is a valuable example of the use of indigenous materials or craftsmanship; or d) The property is representative of the notable design or craft of a builder, designer, or architect; or e) The property embodies or contributes to unique physical characteristics representing an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood or district within the City; or f) The property represents a significant concentration or continuity of site, buildings, structures or objects, unified by past events or aesthetically by plan or physical or natural development; or g) The property embodies or contributes to a unique natural setting or envirorunent constituting a distinct area or district within the City having special character or special historical, architectural or aesthetic interest or value. ,9 City of Saratoga - Exhibit B Designated Landmark Structures 7 Orieinal # Resolution Address Historic or Common Name Architectural Style Criteria 1 4 HP -88 -01 14421 Big Basin Wy. Saratoga Bank Building (1913) Classic Revival a,c,e HP -18 2 24 HP -88 -01 Fruitvale /Saratoga Central Park Orchard n/a a,g HP -3 Ave. 3 36 HP -88 -01 15400 Montalvo Road Villa Montalvo Italian Villa a,b,c,d HP -02 4 37 HP -88 -01 14475 Oak Place Almond Hill (1910 -1912) Shingle Craftsman a,b HP -23 5 38 HP -88 -01 14410 Oak Street Village Library (1927) Mission Revival a,b,c HP -9 6 39 HP -88 -01 14488 Oak Street Saratoga Volunteer Fire Bell n/a a,b HP -12 (1903) 7 43 HP -88 -01 14672 Oak Street William King House (c. 1877) Pioneer /Colonial a,b HP -5 Revival 8 44 HP -88 -01 14683 Oak Street Missionary Settlement House Queen Anne a,b,c,e HP -13 (c.1897) 9 48 HP -88 -01 20399 Park Place Saratoga Foothill Club (1915- Bay Region/Craftsman a,b,c,d,e HP -1 1916) 10 51 HP -88 -01 15231 Quito Road Casa Tierra (1941 -1943) Southwest a,b,c HP -14 11 53 HP -88 -01 18490 Ravenwood Dr. Brandenburg House (1888) Decorative Pioneer a,c HP -15 12 HP -91 -01 14065 Saratoga Ave. Florence Cunningham Craftsman Bungalow b,c,e HP -20 Residence (c. 1930) 13 65 HP -88 -01 20330 Saratoga -Los The Deodars (1912) Mediterranean Villa a,c HP -17 Gatos Road 14 69 HP -88 -01 20450 Saratoga -Los Saratoga Historical Museum False -front Pioneer a,c,e HP -7 Gatos Road (c. 1904 -1905) 15 70 HP -88 -01 20460 Saratoga -Los McWlliams House (1850's) Pioneer Cottage a,c,e HP -10 Gatos Road 7 • Original # Resolution Address Historic or Common Name Architectural Style Criteria 16 74 HP -88 -01 14650 Sixth Street Nardie House (c. 1895) Queen Anne a,c HP -11 17 76 HP -88 -01 13495 Sousa Lane Warner Hutton House Queen Anne a,c HP -21 Moved to: (c. 1896) 13777 Fruitvale Ave. 18 72 HP -88 -01 14051 Saratoga- Neil Carmichael House (1914) Neoclassic a,b HP -22 Sunnyvale Road 19 79 HP -88 -01 11995 Walbrook Dr. Hyde House (1895) Craftsman Bungalow a,c HP -24 8