Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout02-10-04 packetCity of Saratoga AaPRESERVATION COMMISSION AGENDA G L Date: Tuesday, February 10, 2004 8:30 a.m. Place: Warner Hutton House, 13777 Fruitvale Avenue Type: Regular Meeting The HPC will meet at 8:30 for site visits for items III. A, B and C. Please meet in the r` front parking lot by the Warner Hutton House and staff will provide transportation to the sites.�� I. Routine Organization �� (� ��✓ �� �� 5 (�� A. Roll B. Approval of minutes from 1/13/04 C. Posting of Agenda – Pursuant to Government Code Section 54954.2, the agenda was posted on Thursday February 5, 2004 D. Oral & Written Communication - Any member of the public may address the Commission about any matter not on the agenda for this meeting for up to three minutes. Commissioners may not comment on the matter but may choose J) to place the topic on a future agenda.r� A� 6 II. O usiness Village Historic District Update v ,C rant for Historic Park Presentation Preparation III. Ne usiness c���� Review proposed addition to potential historic structure a o a Avenue built in 1941 Review proposed addition to potential historic structure at 12239 Titus built in— Q 1'L�o n eview proposed addition to potential historic structure at 20431 Williams Avenue built in 1922 �c�1��J�w��� °VN- ie�t�� l/S ©�Tj��P�� ics for the March 3, 2004 joint HPC /CC meeting C ����- tld���� National Conference �s�,i 3�A�A5 F. ustard Walk Follow up 'J k Z- w P0 �� S Xj. Orchard Management Calendar ��q°�°S� �o C��vsZ►2� c�ldr -�' g 3� IV. Items to be placed on the next Agend S V. Pendin g Items J-0 iC �o A. Review list of properties wrtIi st tures 50 years and over in age. B. Retreat � cz` S�I.Ts SAN�J °�d� ��� A- Ac--T \3,-) ID G (-� --� r C. Historic Calendar D. Adopt a Tree Program for the Heritage Orchard E. Mills Act Contract F. Historic Preservation Data Base V1. Adjournment 9:00 a.m. Tuesday March 9, 2004, Warner Hutton House, 13777 Fruitvale Avenue In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you are a disabled person and you need a disability - related modification or accommodation to participate in this meeting, please contact the City Clerk's Office at 408.868.1269 or ctderk a.saratoga.ca.us Requests must be made as early as possible and at least one full business day before the start of the meeting. Certificate of Posing of Agenda: I, John F. Livingstone, Associate Planner for the City of Saratoga, declare that the foregoing agenda for the meeting of the Heritage Preservation Commission of the City of Saratoga was posted on February 5, 2004 at the office of the City of Saratoga, 13777 Fruitvale Ave., Saratoga, CA 95070 and was available for public review at that location. The agenda is also available on the City's website at www.saratoga.ca.us. Signed this 5`h day of February 2004 at Saratoga, California. John F. Livingstone, AICP Associate Planner 868.1231 City of Saratoga HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION MINUTES Date: Tuesday, January 13, 2004 9:00 a.m. Place: Warner Hutton House, 13777 Fruitvale Avenue Type: Regular Meeting I. Routine Organization A. Roll Call: PRESENT — Ballingall, Koepernik, Peck, Lowdermilk, Bailey ABSENT — Conrado, one position vacant. GUESTS — Lee Murray, Dennis Leong B. Approval of minutes from 12/9/03 — Approved 5 -0 C. Posting of Agenda — Pursuant to Government Code Section 54954.2, the agenda was posted on Thursday January 8, 2004 D. Oral & Written Communisation - Any member of the public may address the Commission about any matter not on the agenda for this meeting for up to three minutes. Commissioners may not comment on the matter but may choose to place the topic on a future agenda. - None II. Old Business A. Village Historic District — Item discussed. B. Mustard Walk — Planned activities for event. C. Heritage Orchard update — the Fruit trees are ready for delivery and the pump has been installed. D. Business Cards — Item disLsed, the cost would be $128 for cards for 8 people, 250 cards each. E. HPC monitoring of projects — Not recommended by the City Attorney. F. Grant for Historic Park update'; Item discussed. III. New Business A. Elect a Chair by January 31 S` — Patricia Bailey elected Chair, Paul Conrado Vice Chair B. Historic Preservation Data Base — Item discussed C. Name Plates — The HPC decided they were not needed. l IV. Items to be placed on the next Agenda —National Conference, Mustard Walk follow up, Orchard Management Calendar V. Pending Items A. Review list of properties with structures 50 years and over in age. — No discussion B. Retreat - No discussion C. Historic Calendar - No discussion D. Adopt a Tree Program for the Heritage Orchard - No discussion E. Mills Act Contract - No discussion VI. Adjournment 9:00 a.m. Tuesday February 10, 2004, Warner Hutton House, 13777 Fruitvale Avenue In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, if you are a disabled person and you need a disability- related modification or accommodation to participate in this meeting, please contact the City Clerk's Office at 408.868.1269 or ctclerkCc_saratoga.ca.us Requests must be made as early as possible and at least one full business day before the start of the meeting. Certificate of Posing of Agenda: I, John F. Livingstone, Associate Planner for the City of Saratoga, declare that the foregoing agenda for the meeting of the Heritage Preservation Commission of the City of Saratoga was posted on December 4, 2003 at the office of the City of Saratoga, 13777 Fruitvale Ave., Saratoga, CA 95070 and was available for public review at that location. The agenda is also available on the City's website at www.Saratoga.ca.us. Signed this 8`h day of January 2004 at Saratoga, California. John F. Livingstone, AICP Associate Planner 868.1231 CALIFORNIA PRESERVATION CONFERENCE CO- SPONSORS: California Preservation Foundation — Presidio Trust — National Park Service — Fort Point & Presidio Historical Association — Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy MAJOR .SUPPORT: California Office of Historic Preservation TAKS, Educational Sessions and Mobile Workshops. Earn AIA /CES, AICP, MCLE, CLG credits. Architecture/Architectural History - Cultural Landscapes - Heritage Tourism -- Law & Planning 11i"TtrAz '.Nike Missile Site - Fort Baker - Conservatory of Flowers - Ferry Building - Cliff House SF "Old Mint" - Angel Island Immigration Station - Mid - Century Gardens - MORE! 'S ednesday Opening Recept bW t the Presidio Officers Club --- Plenary Session at the Temple Emanu -el — 3- Minute Success Stories at the Presidio Theatre -- CPF Annual Membership meeting at the San Francisco Film Centre — Friday Gala at the San. Francisco Maritime Museum R_ Conference Registration Brochure: Register online January 2004 at www.californiapreservation.org. California Preservation Foundation and Fort Point & Presidio Historical Association members will be sent registration brochures. Conference Registration Fees: Registrations received by March 24, $200 for CPF, Fort Point & Presidio Historical Association, and Golden Gate National Parks Conservancy members; $250 non - members. Includes Educational Sessions and Plenary Session, and a 2004 CPF membership. Extra fees for tours, mobile workshops, and special events. Special package option available. Hotel: Argonaut Hotel, transformed from the historic Haslett Warehouse, at SF Maritime National Historical Park. Special Conference Rate: $140 per night (single or double); reference CPF when booking. Rooms available at this rate on a first -come, First -served basis through April 12. Call ( 866 )415 -0704, www.argonauthotel.com. TO RECEIVE REGISTRATION BROCHURE: epjl@ealiforniapreservation.org or (415)495 -0349. (7770 70 s� �A��c l; City of Saratoga Community Development Department MEMORANDUM TO: HPC FROM: John F. Livingstone AICP, Associate Planner DATE: February 5, 2004 RE: Review of Historic Structures: 14601 Aloha Avenue built in 1941,12239 Titus built in 1880, and 20431 Williams Avenue built in 1922. There are three proposed additions to houses on the Agenda for this meeting. All of the houses are over 50 years old. The following are the options the HPCh as when reviewing the projects: 1. The structure appears to be of historic significance and a Historic Architect should evaluate the structure and proposed addition. 2. The structure does not appear to be of historic significance and the applicant can proceed with the proposed addition. The house on Titus Avenue is currently on the City's Heritage Resource Inventory list. The original structure has been added on to several times, the most recent in 1974. The applicant has stated that the proposed addition does not impact the original structure, only the area that has been previously added to. I ;i mr slm I ' •6++'- � ZSrid '4�p �,,t �A- �- q1{�`3 _fY}'L:Tr' r.S }:i?.i ��.. � � � c•�K � s Ay RI�i. � 4� � eye , � `^� par i1 •+.'.�' ,�" � 7 '91x, �'. w � ! Yc 9yA +�yir�� -Yiik �7 �. .�c„q' L .�y.�,•n.... ,..+-' �•� .. ::.. w. 2004/01/22 4 L. 5 5 ; d *A hmr brr cti t {.f t� t #r & z•. ":'+a 6 � q � 4.Z. *:: .v'i' r .. 'fi d \. .. "� ` �r ) ^'� _ 4'.' A n . �} 2004/01/22 1. .11X�+v%t ''ief!'A r�` .M,': fi e s� _ [J� st+ �$�j �` J -.�•'F yJp,Y.� r �' -, i '. '' e� �/'��/�r�a ���: } �. q�7. !,. � 4" • .a. o9k+w � ''•r• �aYk"+ti '�pp�G..�a`}�..r3. 74, 1 �4 ���r`e.... ..�__ a°r+..w.ws•..^w.+.� o..,..w.......nMa. mw. �� �sk°A.•,7. tt•G�iTas£✓z: -Ci F • � ' •4r ��o/. • may_ Z �� _� ... _ Y���� ", �.`_"'i. Y_:� _ Y� "h,+r � »..._ .. 1e [ a J. � F� t' J� � �.'%' ;h' , . � .y� Rte. f1+, •F >. °y ;� d �"+f- `% "!',fit � •s�� �Y �3 4'�2 �r�r� {. _ ■ "���•�r '•,1'�i..."r �r. � ��'� �x'��s'�s�'��t "��, �';, ik�1.�- "r�y�Rxy�� € ` � 4 � ~•Q,'}g� '�t••e �'� ,Pt 2,. [ �� x �,� ' �r •_9.'�'.4d�Ll.di'r���'�� -�r_.r .. °' :•ye,`ai��. S. � tM.� - d.He. r s -��. � 4 *ef rot. ...-: -a,C 4jA � •:3 ,"'��' p!. c Wf f •' o ,�u `.. °�,Q 4. tc. t,µs ,u' at4-SS y.9 S� "C. 1A y �s .} '�a�� W � ., < "a- �'�r {C,` r. r,s ,ia.. •Fr^r'Yl�s�, _ r lT� E `� •. r�.�- ��kt`�w s e.� p ��'°" %`'f `=�A . �tf"a,..y.�";r"•4d�"�`:,e`_'lF. @ � : r, . ,zy„�{{ x � � � 4 Y P. t9 •�i:4 '� r' L1 P EE •Y. > � F n.' .3 v{. :�. - f A,r � y, a� t e e, _ y� A �' '�.•x�•�s�"'` 1 14(`,x: zfa, !� �s b •iri `C � v �w2 %may„ ♦ • w+ '- - 2004- J01/23 5A 4% " `• .. w f!`+M ,...L -• - T..:..." -aW .. ' =t,.: 4s:: S" "„' °wS:.. ,�'c'.2^?ya�':•:S?":. '.t }! r.J T i a z -A, . f� 1 9 Y� r 2004/01/22 - Atpt LJ s : "t �rrr.:..➢ii rk { v _ - 0204/01/22 ... �� �` \I \ ,i� t \ �;.� � �. �1 '� �, ��� '. 1. ►.2 ' j �, _� i ' =, ,. ,; �_�. I ` I I i, �.�.. r • - ,. :,, :\ "� \. _\ ^�� i �. f ,n.. i 1,'" ,'�:� n � ��-. �Q '' �`� INEET NO. was-r ffL rVATION (REAR) yr . *.o DAVE LAST LLKVATION (F P4DN'n TUAAA RCMEAU 12239 T17US AVE. SARATOGA, CA Michael10m) to t o s t 422 S. Muphy Ave. No.l ■ ■ SiM.77 A 94090 36AM I on NORTH sLjKvA-noN (sion) vw.l.a OEM so MEN IN on ONE on 0 -1 sou-rH stLwvA-noN cacm) Mk-.hcmM klnoeNto ■ TUAAA RUIPEACt H i + + 12239 MUS AVE 422 S. Mu^ Ave. Nol DATE SARATOGA, CA 9 Sw"cde. CA 4M I I I I k in 4DB.7WJM I OWND. wa 5X19TINS ROOF PLAN W v r-a TUAM RLMEAU 12239 MUS AVE. SARATOGA, CA N Mlchoel KlnooNto 0 a r a h i t o o t &Avwvcb. CA 94M6 ■ ■ r0 RLVlar-0 ROOF PLAN VA'. Na ,U� � � Michael KlnoaNth o r o h 12234 TITUS AVE. I WE SARATOGA, CA as t I O t 422 S. Muohy A re. No.l Swnyws. CA 944 I0BJ36.8EB3 EXISTING FLOOR PLAN vr,+o SHEET MD. TUAAA RFJWEACE 12239 TAUS AVE. °"h SARATOGA. CA Michael anoshltc s so o r o h 1 t• o t ■ 422 b. Murphy Ave. No.1 &""a*. U 94M6 40B.i36.WU REVISED FLOOR PLAN VW.+ o TUAAA RV IVEAC.E 12299 TITUS AVE. SARATOGA, CA N Michael Kinoshlta t• c t . 422 S. Mvphy Aw. No.l SW"wlt. CA 94086 ® 408.736.8683 Pl10 losm Ohm a OIt V ADOMOK TYP. {SMA06D0 ea.W I I sws� GARI+d! Wow srnrcrue I TITUS AVB. Orm PLAN N *.w � SKEW NO. Mtcr,oei ar,o"a r 12239 TITUS AVE. 422 S. Mw^ Ave. No.l O R SARATOGA, CA a �CA 94M ' HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY ( #78) IDENTIFICATION 1. Common name: None 2. Historic name: Andersen House 3. Street or rural address: 12239 Titus Avenue City: Saratoga Zip: 95070 County: Santa Clara 4. Parcel number: 386 -28 -002 5. Present Owner: Peter A. & Rosemary Tuana Address: 12239 Titus Avenue City: Saratoga Ownership is: Public: 6. Present Use: Residence DESCRIPTION 7a. Architectural style: Pioneer Zip: 95070 Private: X Original Use: Residence - Farmhouse 7b. Briefly describe the present physical appearance of the site or structure and describe any major alterations from its original condition: This well preserved, one - story, wood frame farmhouse has had many additions over the years. Originally it was a simple rectangle with a front room, one bedroom, and a big kitchen. Today there are four bedrooms and two bathrooms. Centered in the front gable is a small 12 -light gabled attic dormer. The hip roof is composition shingle. The front of the house has matching fixed double sash windows; the upper sash has sixteen small lights, the lower has one large light. The off - center front door is flanked by shutters and is reached by a low brick porch. A major architectural feature of this house is the bay window on the north side, which was added in the early 1900's. The central window in the bay is identical to the two windows in the front of the house. The original tank house is at the rear. (photograph here) 8. Construction date: Estimated: 1890's Factual: 9. Architect: Unknown 10. Builder: Unknown 11. Approx. prop. size Frontage: 85' Depth: 125' approx. acreage 12. Date(s) of enclosed photograph(s): 1988 13. Condition: Excellent: X Good: Fair: Deteriorated: No longer in existence: 14. Alterations: Added 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, enclosed rear porch. 15. Surroundings: (Check more than one if necessary) Open land: Scattered buildings: X Densely built -up: Residential: X Industrial:. Commercial: Other: 16. Threats to site: None known: X Private development: Zoning: Vandalism: Public Works project: Other: 17. Is the structure: On its original site? X Moved? Unknown? 18. Related features: Tankhouse, garage SIGNIFICANCE 19. Briefly state historical and /or architectural importance (include dates, events, and persons associated with the site). This farmhouse was built in the 1880's by James and Christina Andersen who emigrated from Denmark. Their children were all born and raised in the house. The Andersens owned ten acres and could see through their orchard to Saratoga Creek to the east. James was a farmer and raised prunes and few apricots. Their neighbors to the north were the Hansens (Mrs. Hansen was Christina's sister). Hansen School is now located there. Mr. and Mrs. Andersen lived in the house until the 1940's when they moved up to San Mateo to live with their daughter, Alice. 20. Main theme of the historic resource: (If more than one is checked, number in order of importance.) Architecture: Arts /Leisure: Economic /Industrial: Exploration /Settlement: X Government: Military: Religion: Social /Ed.: 21. Sources (List books, documents, surveys, personal interviews and their dates). Nancy McClymont, 6/16/81; Alice Andersen Willey, 7/16/86, 11/30/87; Rosemary Tuana, 11/30/87. 22. Date form prepared: 4/88 By (name): SHPC Organization: City of Saratoga Address: 13777 Fruitvale Ave. City: Saratoga Zip: 95070 Phone: 867 -3438 Locational sketch map (draw and label site and surrounding streets, roads, and prominent landmarks): A NORTH smmmcoomnou - Txonmmv,v=Aooncv Sm.No. - - DEPARTMENT op PARKS AND RECREATION HABS____H/\ER-_-_Lon-_--_-SHLNo.__-__NRStatuo------' ' ^ UTN1: A C HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY B D /- - ~/IDENTIFICATION -- 1. Common name: ' ' %. Histo,icname: 3. Skme o, ru,u| Kress: ^'` ip «k Parcel number:~ 5. P,we,n Owner: pmo�=' ` City Zip o»ip is: Public P,ivute� - O. Present Use: Original use: no— DESCRIPTION �� - 7^ Amhbno*und�v�: T(C)yl�t�Vr ' 7b. Briefly describe the present phyvica appoa,an000fd`ooheo,otrucumanddoscribennvn`ajn,alte,atiorofn,mhs original condition: #74 This well preserved, one story, wood frame Pioneer style farm house has had many additions over the years. Orginally it was a simple rectangle with a "front" room, one bedroom, and a big kitchen. Today 4ere are 4 bedrooms and two bathrooms. In the front there is one small 2 light gabled attic dormer centered in the gable in the composition shingle hip roof. The front of the house has matching double sash windows which are fixed, the upper sash has many small lights (16) , the lower, one large light. The off-center front door is reached by a small low brick porch~ flanked by shutters.The c^^pinaI house had a different front porch. A major architectural feature of this house is the bay window on the north side, this was added in the early 1900's. The central window in the bay is identical to the two windows in the front of the house. The orginal tank house is at the rear. ' ' - 8 Construction oat e' ' Estimated - ` Q` Architect - 10. 8ui|do, - --`- 11` <infeo� _ F rontage |bepth_��[��__ � o,opp mx - acreage. � 1�2. ------cncn�d t� ' --^~ -- 13. Condition: Excellent K Good __Fair— Deteriorated __No longer ^ in'istence Y+ 14. Alterations: pc .5. Surroundings: (Check more than one ifnecessary) Open land Scattered buildings Densely built-up _____ Residential Industrial Commercial - Other: ��"' , 16. Thma�un,�o: None knnwn��_r,�u��deve|upmen�__�_ Zoning Vonda|�m_____ Public Works project -_-_ Other: - - - 17. b the structure: On its original site? Nbved? Unknown? 18. Related features: SIGNIFICANCE 19. Briefly state historical and/or architectural importance (include dates, events, and persons associated with the site.) #74 This pioneer style farm house was built in the James and Christina who immiorated from Denmari_ c hildrenuA^#~, all born and raised in the hou-se. The Andersons had ten acres and could see through their, orchard to Saratoga Creek to the east. James was a farmer and raised prunes and a few apricots, Their neighbors to the north were the Hansens (hr-5 Hansen was Christina's sister). Hansen School is located there. Mr. and Mrs Anderserj lived in the house until the 1940`s when he bacame ill and they moved up to San Mateo to live with their daughter Alice. `1i,f, ' '' 20. Main theme of the historic resource: (if more than one is checked, number in order ofimportnnoe.) Architecture - Arts & Leisure Euonnmiu/|nduot,ia|____Exp|nmtion/Seu|omont Government Military ,RexQionSnxio|/Eduoo,)on 31' 9�56i6e (List books, documents, surveys, personal imamiowa and ' - ihoir. ' U k*-�i(o+ P - Date form-prepared, 11-301- rK 7 City ' ` ' Zip Phone: L000 iono|sketchmuo(dmwund|abe|,boond surrounding streets, roads, and prominent |undma,ks}: /\ NORTH ~` Scott and Christine Barnett 14801 Aloha Ave. Saratoga, CA 95070 (408) 867 -6555 scott@barnettwork.com February 2, 2004 Reference: APN: 517 -10 -018 City of Saratoga 13777 Fruitvale Ave., Saratoga, CA 95070 Attention: Heritage Preservation and Planning Commission To Whom It May Concern: Please find the enclosed remodel submission including current property photos, conceptual site plan, conceptual floor plan and elevations. Our objective is to improve the exterior appearance, add approximately 1000 sq ft. of living space to the rear of the property, add approximately 120 sq ft. living room on the front of the house, and make improvements to the interior living space. In an effort to expedite the review process we are more then willing to cooperate with and take advice from the Heritage Commission if necessary regarding design criteria. Sincerely, Scott and Christine Barnett 7t- -Ap"; Ni om -x- I --j- AV fY{Yyiof . ..... j1/22/2004 4:03pmkz �,—z iEi� t--4 w 77 UINI JIM, ZE! . . . . . . . . . . X INNORI av, 42 .an PIZ ev Vie P(Ro -pvSCD eRnt,,JT CL. t5\)f,i jOAl +�goPosC J3) E= ���57" Ct - 6: -VATivV ex•.re sn.ws / I I ( 11 — — carport not included in total / square footage ®I 9 -11' x 35'8' \ ` /IN \ I \I I IGreat Room \\ -- I I -- - - - - -� I ` I I F-1 \II ` GARAGE �r \ i — T — — BEDROOM I fir\ \ 1- - - -- -- -- - P' 1 / L — — PROPoSeD S ire P- A /J I Existing -7 AddlUorf- Barnett Residence 14601 Aloha Ave Proposed Site Plan � � v O 517 e ° u . OAK STREET OAK NAI NfM Nl/f NSO "so A w A040" O p 19g 911. 9 z�" FOR iNFUAR Ap�THE POLICY NUT.A P .i 1) is C a • �r PCL. A r. 1,00 Ac to ,39 14611 dloba • 20 4& r Iw 146ZS P... } 1 J f /9 PSa1 • PCL.6 • 42 I*V7 Aloha P. - 397--M-30 # PON 140.30 1 3 a. a t r RNIM .Ngp VL.r ' PCL. A 43 !e 14615 14601 AVE 0 P. M. 407- M-49