Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-25-1965 Planning Commission Minutes (2) SUMMARY OF MINUTES CITY OF SAPSTOGA PLA~ING COMMISSION TIME: Monday, 25 October 1965, 7:30 PoMo' PLACE: City Council Chambers, Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga, Califorp. ia TYPE: Regular Meeting I. ROUTINE ORGA~]iTATION The meeting was called to order by Chairman Norton at 7:30 P.M. A. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Cowley, Crisp, Kellum, Johnson, McFall, Norton and O'Rorke. Absent: Ncne B. MINUTES Chairman Norton advised that the minutes of the meeting of 11 October 1965 had not been completed (because of the increased work-load during vacation absences) so would be given consideration at the next regular meeting. II. PUBLIC HF~RINGS The Chairman declared public hearings open for the evening at 7:32 P.M. A. C-80 - Clarence Neale, Saratoga-Sunnyvale Road - ReqUest for. Additional Permitted Uses under Conditional Commercial Zoning - Continued from 11 October 1965 ... :' The continued hearing on C-80 was re-opened at 7:32 P.M. The Secretary read a letter written by W. Hi Lee in support of the sub- ject application. The applicant w~s present but did not wish to make any comment. Mr. Nick Milerich and Gerald Step0vich of Oak Street, Murray Brookman of Pamela Way, B. D. Johnson of Brookglen Drive and Richard Butera of Thelma Avenue all spoke in support of the subject request. Commissioner Crisp read the report of the Subdivision Committee relative to C-80, recommending approval of the request for additional permitted uses under Conditional Commercial Zoning. Commissioner McFall moved, seconded by Commissioner O'Rorke that the public hearing on.C-80 be closed; motion carried unanimously and the hearing was closed at 7:44 P.M. Commissioner Crisp moved, seconded by Commissioner Kellum, to recommend for approval to the City Council the Subdivision Committee Report subject to the following additions: 1. PaRe 2 . Item 2 . ... paragraph. 4 Change "Sporting Goods Shop (Gun Shop)" to "Sporting Goods Shop (Including Gun Sales and Repair Shop)" 2. Page 2 . . paraSraph 4 Add Item 5 - Beauty Shop to existing list. Motion carried unanimously. -.1- Planning Commission Minutes - 25 October. 1965 B. C-87 - MoV. S.Company, Saratoga Avenue - Request for Change of Zoning from "A" (Agricultuz'al) to "R-M-4,000 P-C" (}bltiple Residential Planned Co~mmnity) - Continued from 11 October 1965 The public hearing on C-87 was resumed at 7:50 P.M. The Secretary read 1) a letter from the Saratoga Chamber of Commerce filed in support of this application and 2) a letter from Dr. Abram requesting an extension of C-87. Mr. Kocher, Saratoga Merchant, 'presented a petition, with forty (40) signatures, opposing this request. Charles Murphy, Peach Hill .Road, was present and stated 1) that his sign~- tu:ce ~as on. the petiti. m~, but he had not seen the petition in type 2) he did not want the contents of the petition to be his final word and 3) he felt that the Planning Commissfon should make a study and do what is best for Saratoga. R. E. Kauffman, Glen Brae Drive, was present and 1) spoke in favor of the subject application and 2) stated that he felt that this would be the best use of the land .other than orchards. Mr. Sam Hernandez,.Big Basin way, stated that he was opposed to the appli- cation for the same reasons Mr. Kocher stated. in his petition. On the basis of the request made by Dr. Abrams, Chairman Norton (at 8:06 P.M.) directed C-87, M.V.S. continued until the next regular meeting. C. Ordinance NS-3.11 - Proposed Amendment to Ordinance NS-3 - Clarifying certain definitions, adding the definition of "KEEPING", clarifying sections.relating to the keeping of horses in residential districts, and adding sections relating tc horses for riding lessone - Continued from .11 October 1965 The'continued hearing on Ordinance NS-3.11 was resumed at 8:07 P.M. The Secretary stated that Horse' Ordinances from other cities had been received. Fir. QuintonManchester, Via Regina, advised that he and the group of about fifteen (15) people with him were present to verify what Mr. Teerlink had said at the last meeting. After discussion, Chairman Norton (at 8:14 P.M.)-directed Ordinance NS-3.11, continued until the next regular meeting on 8 November 1965 and referred same to Subdivision Committee for study and a report and to give the Sub- division Committee time to meet with a representative from the group mentioned above. D. C-92 - Columbus-Founders Savings and Loan Association, Wardell Road - Request for Change of Zoning from '~-1-15,000" and "R-I-40,000" (Single Family Residential) to "R-I-20,000" (Single Family Residential) The public hearing on C-92 ~ms Opened at 8:16 P.M. The Secretary advised that a Notice of Hearing had been published and.l) read a letter from ~. Frank R. Maggi, Vice-President of Columbus-Founders Savings and Loan Association, listing the reasons ~y the proposed Change of Zoning would be in the public interest and ~) read a letter fromMr. and Mrs. A. Ottenberg stating the reasons why they were opposed to this request. There was no one present who wished to comment with regard to this matter. The Chairman (at 8:23 P.M.) directed C-92 continued until the next regular meeting and referred same to the Subdlvison Cor~aittee for study and a report at that time. -2- Planning Commission Minutes - 25 October 1965 II. E. V-263 - Kieth Siegrist, Portos Drive - Request for Variance in connection with Street-Side'Setback Requirement and Site ~ea Requirement. The public hearing on V-263 was Opened at 8:24 P.M. The Secretary advised 1) that Notices of Hearing had been mailed and 2) that the following correc- tions were required: Line 3 of Descriptive Paragraph Change "northwest" to read "northeast". Line 4 of Descriptive Paragraph Change "(Lot 22 - Tract 2544)" to read "(Lot 32 - Tract 2544)". The Secretary read a letter from Mr. and Mrs. Ernest G. Murray stating their reasons for opposing this application. Mr. Kieth Siegrist, the applicant was present and explained 1) that the house could be reduced in size 2) a smaller house, but a nice house could be put on this lot and 3) that without the Variance the development of the property was not feasible. Mrs. Tarroni Mr. James Grafton, and Mrs. Freeman of Portos Drive and Harry Carlson of Myren Court were present and voiced their objections to this application. After discussion, Chairman Norton (at 8:36 P.M.) directed V-263, Kieth Sicgrist, continued until the meeting on 8 November 1965 and referred same to Variance Committee for study and a report. On the basis of the foregoing, Kieth. Siegrist, requested SDR-603 be contihued until the next regular meeting on 8 November 1965~ The Chairman declared public hearing~ closed for the evening at 8:36 P.M~ RECESS ANDRECONVENE Chairman Norton extended a welcome to Councilman Larry Tyler. and to MeSdames Kauffman and Parker of the Good Government Group and Mrs. Ottenberg of the League of Women Voters. He also expressed appreciation for the coffee served by Mesdames Parker and Kauffman at recess. III. SUBDIVISIONS AND BUILDING SITES A. SD-592 - Western Hills Investment Company, Pierce Road - Subdivision 26 Lots - Continued from 11 October 1965 The Secretary read a letter, from the applicant, requesting an extension of forty-five (45) days since the requested site developemtn plan for this proposed plan was not quite completed. The applicant ~qas not present. Commissioner Crisp recommended that SD-592, Western Hills Investment Company, be continued on the basis of.the above mentioned request. Chairman Norton so directed. B. SDR-600 - Ben H. ·Smith, Pierce Road - Building Site Approval - 4 Lots Continued from 11 October 1965 Mr. Jim Cole, present to represent the applica=~, expressed concern over Specific Condition 2 of uhe Building Site Committee Report and inquired about the possibility of posting a bond for this task. Commissioner Crisp, with concurrence of the other members of the Committee assured Mr. Cole that this procedure would be accetable. -3-. P!annin~ Co~ission Minutes - 25 October 1965 III. B. SDR-600 - Ben H. Smith, Pierc& Road Commissioner Crisp moved, seconded by Commission Johnson, that the Building Site Committee Report of 25 October 1965 relative to SDR-600 be adopted and that the tentative map (Exhibit "A", filed 1 October 1965) be approved in accordance with the site development plan (Exhibit "B", filed 14 October 1965) subject to the conditions set forth in said report; motion carried unanimously. C. SDR-601 - George Flynn, Pierce Road - Building Site Approval - 4 Lots - Continued from litOctober 1965 Jim Cole, representing the applicant, expressed satisfaction with the proposed conditions of approval. Commissioner Crisp moved, seconded by Commissioner McFall, that the Building Site Cou~Littee Report of 25 October 1965 relative to SDR-601 be adcpted and that the tentative map' (Exhibit "A", filed 1 October 1965) in accordance with the site development plan (Exhibit "B", filed 14 October 1965) subject to the conditions set forth in said report; motion carried unanimously. D. SDR-602 - Church of the Ascension, Prospect Road - Building Site Approval - 1 Lot The applicant ms not present. C~issioner Crisp, seconded by Commissioner Kellum, that the Building Site Committee Report Of 25 October 1965 relative to SDR-602 be adopt- ed and that the tentative map.(Exhibit "A", filed 7 October 1965) be approved subject to the conditions outlined in said report; motion carried u~animohsly. E. SDR-603 - Kieth Sie~rist, Portos Drive - Building Site Approval - 4 Lots At the request of the applicant SDR-603 was continued until the next regular meeting on 8 November.1965. F. SD-604 - Evan V. Judd, Austin. Way - Subdivision Approval - 5 Lots Dr. Hardy, present to represent the applicant, expressed satisfaction with the proposed conditions of approval. Commissioner Crisp moved, seconded by Commissioner Jchnson, that the Subdivision Committee Report of 25 October 1965, relative to SD-604, be adopted and that the tentative map (Exhibit "A", filed 15 October 1965) be approved subject to the conditions set forth in said report; motion carried unanimously. IV. DESIGN REVIEW A. A-195 - Clarence Neale, Saratoga-Sunnyvale Road - Preliminary Design Review - Commercial Building - Continued from 11 October 1965 Commissioner Cowley requested'that A-195 be continued inasmuch as ~-. Neale was preparing a newmap'to present to the Commission. On the basis of this request,:ehairman Norton directed A-195, continued until the next regular meeting. B. A-196 - Quito Shopping Center, Cox Avenue - Final Design Review - Identification Sign - Continued from 11 October 1965 Since there had been no further information from the applicau.t regarding this matter Commissioner"' Cowley recommendd~ that A-196 be continued until the next regular meeting. Chairman Norton so directed. Planning Commission Minutes - 25 October 1965 IV. DESIGN REVIEW C. A-197 - Church of the Ascencion, Prospect Avenue - Preliminary Design Review - Church Buildins Commissioner Cowley advised that the Committee had reviewed the subject plans and recommended approval zfor Preliminary Design Review subject to 1) the elimination of the ingress off Prospect Avenue and 2) the elimin- ation of the egress to Prospect Avenue. Commissioner Cowley moved, seconded by Commissioner O'Rorke, that Preliminary Design approval be granted A~197, in accordance with Exhibit "A" subject to the change stated in the above paragraph. D. A-198 - A to Z Rental Center, Saratoga-Sunnyvale Road - Final Design Review - Identification Sign The applicant was not present. It was moved by Commissioner Cowley and seconded by Commissioner Johnson that Final Design approval be granted A-198, A to Z Rental Center, as shown on Exhibit "A"; motion carried unanimously. E. A-199 - Edie's Ice Cream, Blue Hills Shopping Center - Final Design Review - Directional Sign Commissioner Cowley recommended 2~.nial of this application, because of the fact that a flashing sign is involved. After discussion Commission Cowley moved, seconded by Commissioner O'ROrke, that A-199, Edie's ICe Cream, Be denied Final Design approval; motion carried unanimously. F. A-200 ~ Pau~··~lana~an~ Big p~s~n .Way - ~nal D~sign Review - Retail Store Commissioner Cowley advised that the Committee was not prepared to make a reconmendation at this time since the sketch submitted in connection with A-200 was not adequate and a new presentation of same would be necessary for further study. On this basis, Chairman Norton directed this matter continued until the next regular meeting on 8 November 1965. G. A-193 - Prince of peace Lutheran Church, Cox Avenue - FiDal Design Review - Church Building The applicant was not present., After a brief discussion, Commissioner Cowley moved, seconded by Commis- sioner O'Korke, that Final Design approval be granted in connection with A-193, Prince of Peace Lutheran Church, as sho~.~ on' Exhibit "A-I"; motion carried unanimously. H. Vern L. Adair - Request for Interrupatation of Sign Requirements Commissioner Cowley stated that the proposed sign exceeds the size allowed by the ordinance and that the Payless sign would overshadow the allowed sign for this property. Commissioner Johnson advised, that when the zoning was changed on this property, there was some discussion in regard to giving this property special consideration. Commissioner Crisp stated that' the same consideration should be given to the prcperties adj~c~zt to th~.~; property. Chairman Norton stated he would be willing to consider a Variance on this property if it served a good purpose. Plannin~ Commission l.iinutes 25 ,'}ctober 1965 IV. H. ~ern L. Adair - p~_q!,e_~t for ln~et~tlon of Si,.~n Requirements Commissioner O'Rorke advised, that the area is encompassed by Prospect Avenue, Saratoga Avenue and the Freeway. Commissioner McFall state~ because of the locality of this property, it might be justifiable to consider 'a Variance. Chairman Norton then directed this matter continued until the next regular meeting on 8 Noventer 1965. V. CITY CGI~CIL REPORT Commissioner Cowley gave a brief report on items discussed at the City Couucil meeting on 20 October 1965 with emphasis on items of particular intemcst to the Commission. VI. NEW BUSINESS A. SDR-400 - R. J. Hunter, Pierce Road - Request for Extension - Continued from !1 October 1965 The applicant. was present. The Secretary read the Staff Report recommending the request for a one (1) year extension be granted subject to the following additional condition: "Provide underground utilities."' After discussion,' Commissioner Crisp moved, seconded by Commissioner Kellum, that an extension be grantgd in connection with SDR-400 for a period of one (]) year subjec~ to the above lis~ed additional condition; motion carried unanimously. B. SDR-564 - Request {c~ Deletion of Curb and Gutter.Requirement After reviewing the report, Commissioner Crisp moved, seconded by Commissioner Kellum, that the report of the Subdivision Committee relative to SDR-564 recommending denial of this request, but sub- stituting the R-'36 (rolled curb and gutter) for the ~rtical curb and gutter, be aptroved by the Commission and forwarded to the City Council as the recommendation of the Commission; motion carried unanimously. C. Proposed Amendment to Section 3.5 of Ordinance NS-3. Commissioner Cowley, with concurrence of the Commission, l) advised that the word "street" inserted before the word "cul-de-sa~" on the proposed amendment would give clarification and 2) recommended that this matter be continued until the.next regular meeting on ~ November 1965. Chairman Norton so directed. C. Proposed Change in Existing Permitted Uses in C-S (Commercial ~rvice) Zoning Districtand Additions Thereto Commissioner Crisp reviewed the report on this matter of new Conditional Uses and modifying some uses in the C-S Distizct. Mr. Cowley suggested that the requirement for boat sales and automobile sales to be in a completely enclosed structure be eliminated. C'ommissioner McFall stated, that the City still wou~d need some control over the screening of these uses. Chairman ~]orton directed this matter continued until th~ next regular meeting and asked the Secretary to prepare a composite l~.st of the existing permitted and conditionaluses and any new uses proposed. -6- Plannin~ Commission Minutes - 25 October 1965 VIIi. CO~MFNICATIONS A. W]{ITTEN 1. SD-525 - Wynn and Duma_s~ Wardeil Road - Request for E~tension The Secretary read a letter requesting an extension of one (1) year in connection with SD-525. After brief discussion, Commissioner Crisp moved, seconded by Commissioner Kellu~.that an extension of one (1) year from the present date of expiration be granted in connection with SD-525; motion carried unanimously. 2. SDR-440 - Shannon Li~htfoot~ Springer Avenue - Request for Extension The Secretary read a letter requesting an extension of sixty (60) days in connection with SDR-440. After a brief discussion, Commissioner Crisp moved, seconded by Commissioner McFall, that an extension of sixty (60) days from the present date of expiration be granted in connection with SDR-440; motion carried uDJnimously. 3. Paul Masson Champagne Cellars~'Saratoga Avenue - Signs The Secretary 1) briefly reviewed a letter received from Paul Masson concerning Directional and Identification Signs for the Champagne Cellars on Saratoga Avenue and 2) suggested that this might be referred to the Design Review Committee for a study and report. Chairman Norton so directed. B. ORAL ~X. ADJOURNMENT Chairman Norton declared the meeting adjourned at 10:08 P.M. Respectfully submitted, Z,<' ~ .........~=,/'. ~ '.'6:'... .. .~:-~'~.,?:~,...>....,.~:"' ....... ,...../. -.. .... Stanley M. ~a~ker, Secretary Saratoga PIanuing Commission s~r~/jm1 CITY OF SARATOGA PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA TIME: Monday, 25 October 1965, 7:30 P. M. PLACE: City Council Chambers, Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga, California TYPE: Regular Meeting I. ROUTINE ORGANIZATION A. ROLL CALL B. MINUTES II. PUBLIC HEARINGS A. C-80 - Clarence Neale, Saratoga-Sunnyvale Road - Request for Additional Permitted Uses under Conditional Commercial Zoning - Continued from ~1 October 1965 B. C-87 - M. V. S. Company, Saratoga Avenue - Request for Change of Zoning from "A" (Agricultural)to "R-M-4,000 P-C" (Multiple Residential Planned Community) - Continued from 11 October 1965 C. Ordinance NS-3.11 - Proposed Amendment to Ordinance NS-3 - Clarifying certain definitions, Adding the definition of "KEEPING", Clarifying sections relating to the keeping of horses in residential districts, and Adding sections relating to horses for riding lessons - Continued from 11 October 1965 D. C-92 - Columbus-Founders Savings ~and Loan Association, Wardell Road - Request for Change of Zoning from "R-l-15,000" and'R-I-40,000" (Single Family Residential)'to "R-1-20~000" (Single Famil~Residential) E. V-263- Kieth Siegrist, Portos Dr~ve - Request for Variance in connection with Street-Side Setback Requirement and. Site Area Requirement III. SUBDIVISIONS AND BUILDING SITES A. SD-592 - Western Hills Investmen~ Company, Pierce Road - Subdivision - 26 Lots - Continued from 11 October 1965 B. SDR-600- Ben H. Smith, Pierce Road - Building Site Approv~,l - 4 Lots - Continued from 11 October 1965 C. SDR-601- George Flynn, Pierce Road - Building. Site ApDrova! - 4 Lots Continued frp~ 11 October 1965 D. SDR-602- Church of the Ascension, ProspeCt Road - Building Site Approval - 1 Lot E. SDR-603- Kieth Siegrist~ Portos Drive - BuildinR Site Approva!. - 4 Lots F. SD-604 - .Evan V. Judd~ Austin Way - Subdivision - 5 Lots IV. DESIGN REVIEW A. A-195 - Clarence Neale, Saratoga~Sunnyvale Road - Preliminary Design Review - Commercial Building - Continued from 11 October 1965 B. A-196 - Quito Shopping Center, Cox Avenue - Final Design Review - Identi- fication Sign - Continued from 11 October 1965 C. A-197 - Church of the Ascencion, Prospect Avenue - Preliminary Design Review - Church Planning Commission Agenda - 25 October 1965 IV. D. A-198 - A to Z Rental Center, Saratoga-Sunn]~ale Road - Final Design Review - IdentificationlSign E. A-199 - Edie's Ice Crean, Blue Hills Shopping Center - Final Design Review - Directional Sign F. A-200 - ~aul FlanaSen, Bi~ Basin Way - Final Design Review - Retail Store [ G. A-193 - Prince of Peace Lutheran Church, Cox Avenue - Final DesignReview - Church Building V~ CITY COUNCIL REPORT VI~. NEW BUSINESS VII~ OLD BUSINESS A. SDR-400 - R. J. Hunter, Pierce Road - Request for Extension - Continued from 11 October 1965 B. SDR-564 - Request for Deletion of Curb and Gutter Requirement C. Proposed Amendment to Section 3.5 of Ordinance NS-3 D. Proposed Change in Existing Permitted Uses in C-S (Commercial Service) Zoning District and Additions Thereto VIIIv COMMUNICATIONS A. WRITTEN B. ORAL IX. ADJOURNmeNT -2-