Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutFRUITVALE AVENUE 15095HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY ( #29) IDENTIFICATION 1. Common name: Caswell House 2. Historic name: Fair Oaks 3. Street or rural address: City: Saratoga 4. Parcel number: 397 -19 -10 15095 Fruitvale Avenue Zip: 95070 County: Santa Clara 5. Present Owner: Lee & Joan Fischer Address: 15095 Fruitvale Avenue City: Saratoga Ownership is: Public: 6. Present Use: Residence Zip: 95070 Private: X Original Use: Residence DESCRIPTION 7a. Architectural style: Prairie with Classical Revival elements 7b. Briefly describe the present physical appearance of the site or structure and describe any major alterations from its original condition: This house is two stories set over a raised basement. The oak and glass front door is reached by a staircase flanked by brick pillars, and is set under a portico supported by Ionic columns and topped by a columned balustrade. Two thrusting wings flank the entrance, marked on the main floor by impressive arched windows in the center of each wing. There are several garage and storage buildings on the property which are in poor repair. The house is approached from the street by a circular drive bordered by extensive lawn. (photograph here) 8. Construction date: Estimated: Factual: 1905 9. Architect: Unknown 10. Builder: Unknown 11. Approx. prop. size: Frontage: 175' Depth: 493' approx. acreage 12. Date(s) of enclosed photograph(s): 1988 13. Condition: Excellent: X Good: Fair: Deteriorated: No longer in existence: 14. Alterations: 15. Surroundings: (Check more than one if necessary) Open land: Scattered buildings: X Densely built -up: Residential: X Industrial: Commercial: Other: 16. Threats to site: None known: X Private development: Vandalism: Public Works project: Other: 17. Is the structure: On its original site? X Moved? 18. Related features: Garage, storage buildings Zoning: Unknown? SIGNIFICANCE 19. Briefly state historical and /or architectural importance (include dates, events, and persons associated with the site). Fair Oaks was built in 1905 to replace an earlier house destroyed by fire. The house was purchased from the Drown estate in 1929 by William Sherman, Chairman of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners. He was retired from positions as both Fire and Police Chiefs of San Francisco. During December, 1941, a carriage house on the property was used to house soldiers from Ft. Ord in Monterey County. The house was purchased by the Caswell family in 1951. Helen Caswell is a writer and artist, known especially for her paintings of children. 20. Main theme of the historic resource: (If more than one is checked, number in order of importance.) Architecture: 1 Arts /Leisure: 2 Economic /Industrial: Exploration /Settlement: Government: Military: Religion: Social /Ed.: 21. Sources (List books, documents, surveys, personal interviews and their dates). Reprint of interview with Mrs. Helen Caswell for home tour brochure, 1981. 22. Date form prepared: 4/88 By (name): SHPC Organization: City of Saratoga Address: 13777 Fruitvale Ave. City: Saratoga Zip: 95070 Phone: 867 -3438 Locational sketch map (draw and label site and surrounding streets, roads; and prominent landmarks): NORTH .10S Rot CI :Y OF SARATOGA PLANNING DEPARTMENT IDENTIFICATION Street Address 150 �JGtit/�I/� Historic Name 7h 2 / req I/I/ use Present Owner , Le /SG%j,er Address ���5' �/"(,G��(/�1�6 Zyr 9J0 7 Present Use Other Past Uses DESCRIPTION Original Use CULTURAL RESOURCES INVENTORY INVENTORY- # PHOTOGRAPH TAKEN APN 617- /9 —la (date) Briefly describe the present physical appearance of the site or structure and describe any major alterations from its original condition: Approximate property size: Location sketch map (draw and label site Lot size (in feet) Frontage %� and surrounding streets, roads, and pro- Depth minent landmarks) � .� or approximate acreage Condition (check one): Excellent ( ) Good ( ) Fair ( ) Deteriorated ( ) No longer in existence ( ) Is the feature: Altered? ( ) Unaltered? ( ) N .r Threats to site: None known ( ) Private Development ( ) Zoning ( ) Public Works Project ( ) Vandalism ( ) Other ( ) Primary exterior building material: Stone ( ) Brick ( ) Stucco ( ) Adobe ( ) Wood ( ) Other ( ) Is the structure: On its original site? ( ) Moved? ( ) Unknown ( ) Year of initial construction This date is: Factual ( ) Estimated ( ) Architect (if known) Builder ( if-known) Related features: Barn ( ) Carriage House ( ) Outhouse ( ) Shed(s) ( ) Formal garden(s) ( ) Windmill ( ) Watertower /Tankhouse ( ) Other ( ) None ( ) SIGNIFICANCE Briefly state historical and /or architectural importance (include dates, events, and persons associated with the site when known): Source (books, documents, surveys, personal interviews, and their dates): Form prepared by: Date: -- �sa � �I1 04 July 13, 1988 Q11aD ZAI A 'XQ)0& 13777 FRUITVALE AVENUE • SAR.ATOGA. CALIFORNIA 95070 (408) 867 -3438 Mr. and Mrs. Lee Fischer 15095 Fruitvale Avenue Saratoga, CA 95070 Dear Mr. and Mrs. Fischer: COUNCIL MEMBERS: Karen Anderson Martha Clevenger Joyce Hlava David Moyles Donald Peterson The Saratoga Heritage Preservation Commission has recently completed —a comprehensive Inventory of historic resources in our community. We are pleased to notify you that your residence at 15095 Fruitvale Avenue meets the criteria for being included on this list. The purpose of the Heritage Resource Inventory is to establish a list of documented historic properties in Saratoga. The Heritage Preservation Commission was assigned the responsibility for preparing the Inventory by the City Council in 1982. Each property on the list has been identified as reflecting and being a part of the unique history of Saratoga. The Inventory has been prepared in accordance with guidelines established by the State Office of Historic Preservation, with data gathered from a variety of sources, including historic documents and books, interviews with local citizens, and existing county and state inventories that contain information on Saratoga properties. Being listed on the Inventory does not carry any form of special requirements or restrictions affecting the use, improvement, alteration or even the demolition of your property. As an Inventory property, however, you will be able to make use of the State Historic Building Code, an alternative set of building regulations that are intended to facilitate the rehabilitation and preservation of historic buildings. In addition, your property may qualify for designation as a Saratoga Heritage Landmark, a special category of outstanding and exemplary historic properties that are identified in the community by a handsome bronze plaque. We have enclosed the entire Inventory list and the individual Inventory form for your property, which gives information about the building, the property and its history. We would appreciate your review of this form to let us know if there are any changes or additions to the form you wish to. include. We also anticipate that there are additional historic resources in the community that we may have overlooked or have not fully documented yet; if you know of any that are not on the list, please let us know. If you have any questions, please direct them to the through Valerie Young, our staff person,at City Hall One of the Commissioners will be happy to meet with you the Inventory and answer any questions you may have. Sincerely, Members of the Heritage Preservation Commission Elizabeth Ansnes Roy Cameron Norm Koepernik Shar andsness BarTarAesterA rren Heid, Cha Commission (867- 3438). to discuss 5^6q S 1� /Xz Abu, 6uf,,vLaJ w=- 4v ci5tu�a r � 0 CL I�tor.�ne I S 02.J �C_pi 5, C@ a� -eve -� s b� �•yv,,,. ��''"�� , �)ftk'4 �y Lae-;� 2 7&.) Mum � 'yu; k "U� IgOb OY ,ear CITY OF SARATOGA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT FACSIMILE TRANSMITTAL SHEET TO: FROM: COMPANY: DATE: FAX NUMBER: TOTAL NO. OF PAGES INCLUDING . :� Tf- Af 71-5 COVER: PHONE NUMBER: SENDER'S PHONE NUMBER: RE: SENDER'S FAX NUMBER: 408 - 867 -8555 O URGENT 0 FOR REVIEW 0 PLEASE COMMENT O PLEASE REPLY NOTES /COMMENTS: 13777 FRUITVALE AVE, SARATOGA, CA 95070 ICI � o �rc ON IS 09,-s WA L1�7 A4 39l7-F47i5 1 � 4 PRWAR` r. 1� V > `t Page 1 of 12 *Resource Name or #: (Assigned by recorder) 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga P1. Other Identifier: "Fair Oaks" / Caswell House *P2. Location: ❑ Not for Publication ® Unrestricted a. County: Santa Clara and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a Location Map as necessary.) b. USGS 7.5' Quad Cupertino Date 1980, Photorevised S 7 T 8S R 1W B.M. Mt. Diablo c. Address 15095 Fruitvale Ave City Saratoga Zip 95070 d. UTM: (Give more than one for large and /or linear resources) Zone 10S 587402 mE 4122955 mN e. Other LOcatlonal Data: (e.g.. parcel #, directions to resource, elevation, etc., as appropriate) Assessor's Parcel Number: 397 -19 -010 *P3a Description: (Describe resource and its major elements. Include design, materials, condition, alterations, size, setting, and boundaries) Summary Description The subject house and property are on the west side of Fruitvale Avenue within the city limits of Saratoga. The wood -frame residence is an excellent example of Classical Revival residential architecture with some Prairie Style influences. It has a compact, basically rectangular, footprint with some projecting full - height bays, and features a complex roof form with both hipped and gabled roofs. The main floor level is built above a full walkout basement, which supports the house's imposing scale and massing, and large formal stairways are centered at both the front and rear elevations. A more modest staircase extends to the main level on the south side as well. The house is more than two full stories at the front corners where the roof features two hipped -roof wings flanking the front porch; the main body of the house is one - and -a -half stories under a gabled roof with hipped dormers. Distinctive Classical Revival details include the Greek key frieze, Ionic porch columns, leaded glass windows, and Palladian windows at the front portion of the house. Prairie Style influences are found in the ribbon windows at the second floor, the proportions of the (See Continuation Sheet Page 3) *P3b. Resource Attributes: (List attributes and codes) HP2 *P11. Report Citation. (Site survey report and other sources or enter none) None It of District ❑ Other (isolates, etc.) P5b. Description of Photo: (view, date, accession #) Front of house from northeast, January, 2003 *P6. Date Constructed /Age and Sources: ® Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both *P7. Owner and Address: Rama and Poonam Shukla 14765 Live Oak Lane Saratoga, CA 95070 *P8. Recorded by: (Name, affiliation, and address) L. Dill, A. Halberstadt Dill Design Group 110 N Santa Cruz Ave Los Gatos, CA 95030 'P9. Date Recorded: 2 -13 -2003 *P10. Survey Type: (Describe) Intensive *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑ Sketch Map ® Continuation Sheet ® Building, Structure and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling State Record ❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other (List) DPR 523A (1/95) *Required information ' "State of�California „� `QEPARTMENT, OF,PI ' BUILDING STR Page 2 of 12 B1. Historic Name: "Fair Oaks" B2. Common Name: Caswell House *NRHP Status Code 4 *Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder) 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga B3. Original use: Residential B4. Present Use: Residential *B5. Architectural Style: Classical Revival with Prairie Style influences *B6. Construction History: (Construction date, alterations, and date of alterations) Built circa 1906, a sun room was added in the 1940s or 1950s. Other alterations include a new second story room addition within the original footprint, the enclosure of the recessed rear porch and the addition of new windows at a new side balcony. *B7. Moved? ® No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8. Related Features: Garage, shed, secondary residence, arbors, pool, stable, and pond. Mature trees. B9a Architect: Unknown b. Builder: Unknown *B10. Significance: Theme Architecture Area Saratoga Period of Significance Circa 1906 Property Type Residential Applicable Criteria 3 (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity.) The main house on the property, originally built in the early twentieth century as a single - family residence and known locally as "Fair Oaks," was owned by only a few families in the early twentieth century, but has changed hands every few years since the early 1980s, and has been a rental property several times. The house is also known as "The Caswell House" for the Caswell family, locally noted artists and musicians, who lived in the house from 1952 until about 1982. The house was featured as a Decorator Showcase House at one time, when it was renovated and opened for tours to benefit the San Josh Symphony in the early 1980s. 15095 Fruitvale is listed in the Historic Survey of the City of Saratoga and was reportedly built after 1906 by William and Marcelline Sherman of San Francisco. The property is within the original boundaries of the Quito Rancho. Historical Overview The Quito Rancho The first settlement in the vicinity of the property at 15095 Fruitvale Avenue by non - indigenous people occurred in the 1840s. A rancho of three - square leagues known as the Quito Rancho, over 13,000 acres, was granted in 1841 to Josh Zenon Fernandez and Josh Noriega. The rancho property was located in the western (See Continuation Sheet Page 5) B11. Additional Resource Attributes: lust attributes and codes) N/A *B12. References: Arbuckle, Clyde 1968 Santa Clara County Ranchos. San Josh: Rosicrucian Press 1986 Clyde Arbuckle's History of San Jose. San Jos@: Memorabilia of San Josh Baker, John 1994 American House Styles. New York: W. W. Norton s Co. (See Continuation Sheet Page 6) B13. Remarks: Proposed remodeling project *B14. Evaluator: Leslie Dill *Date of Evaluation: 2 -13 -2003 DPR 523B (1/95) *Required information State of California The�sResou�rceslAgency DEPARTMENT�OP! PARKS,AND Vii. a' i i CONTINUATION .. _ ran' s Page 3 of 12 Resource Name or # (Assigned by Recorder) 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga Recorded By: Leslie Dill and April Halberstadt Date: 2 -13 -2003 x Continuation Update Continued from P3a Description Page 1 expressed floor levels, and the deeply overhanging, boxed eaves. The rear of the house has more simple detailing, including a flat frieze at the eave line, which is framed top and bottom by dentil moldings (this frieze aligns in height with the more decorative front frieze), and the individual double -hung windows that are spaced regularly throughout the house. The lower exterior walls are clad with horizontal lap siding, culminating in the frieze line at the second floor level and eaves. The upper floors at the front of the house are clad in tongue- and - groove flat board siding except at the south side facade where the upper wall has been shingled. A watercourse visually divides the basement and main levels. The interiors are generally intact although some modifications have been made recently. The residence is situated in the center of its approximately two -acre parcel, with a generous front lawn in the center of a circular driveway, and a driveway that passes the north side of the house to the rear detached accessory structures. Elaboration of Exterior Description Front (East): The front of the house, facing east, is symmetrical. Each two -story corner wing features a centered Palladian window at the main level (a low- arched window with a leaded glass fan pattern tops the wider center unit of three double -hung wood windows), and a centered ribbon window with four wood casement sash at the upper level. The basement level has small, centered windows as well. Projecting in front of the two -story wings is a traditional Classical Revival porch with roof balcony. It features a cluster of three Ionic columns at each corner, a classical entablature at the eave line, and a classical balustrade (mostly missing) at the second floor with pedestals at the corners. The front of the balustrade has been covered with lattice panels. Stepped, lap -sided walls flank the porch steps, and the porch is surrounded with a classical balustrade. The front entrance is recessed between the house wings, and the front door is oak with wide sidelights that feature stained glass lites. A large gable end marks the front of the one - and -a -half story portion of the house; it is recessed behind the side wings, and serves as the backdrop for the upper balcony. North Side: The north side of the house shows a clear demarcation between the highly stylistic front portion and the more simple rear body of the house. The more formal two -story front section contains symmetrical leaded glass windows on both sides of a full- height brick chimney at the main level, while the rear portions contain simple one - over -one double -hung windows placed regularly in the walls. At the center of this side is the projecting dining room wing with a second full- height brick chimney. This chimney is flanked on each side with a double - hung window, and the projecting wing has windows facing front and rear as well, creating corner windows. Toward the rear of the north facade, a contemporary cantilevered bay window has been added at the kitchen wing. A hipped dormer with two windows faces north at the center of the roof. The chimneys are distinctive for their tight brick joints and deep red color. Rear (West): The main house roof at the rear presents a wide, off - center gable end above a shallow hip eave. Centered in the gable end in the upper floor is a pair of double -hung windows. Sheltered under the hip eave to the south end of the gable is a slightly projecting porch wing. The porch was apparently originally open and recessed under this hip eave, but has been enclosed with contemporary arched French doors and sidelights. The kitchen wing projects from the main wing on the north side of the rear elevation. This projecting wing is capped by a hip roof below the level of the main house roof. It has a single window centered at the main level above a basement door at grade. Between the kitchen wing and the porch projection is a single window at the main level centered above another at the basement level. These windows are in the same plane as the gable end. Continuing in this plane to the south of the main gabled roof is a hipped -roof wing at the main level and basement. Although including original double -hung windows, the south side of this wing has been modified, apparently in the 1940s or 50s, to include a sun porch. The sun porch is partially situated under the original roof and partly projecting to the south under a shed roof addition. An added half -story protrudes above the hip roof. It has different siding and windows than the rest of the upper level. South Side: This facade has had a number of modifications over time. The front portion has the original ribbon windows at the second floor, but the original siding has been concealed at that level with shingles. The main level at the front wing has contemporary picture windows and a new doorway that opens onto a cantilevered porch addition supported by timber knee braces. A new shed roof protects this balcony, and is also supported by knee braces. The center portion of this facade appears original. It features the simple frieze and individual double -hung windows of the rest of the original house, and includes a half -story above the hipped roof. This half -story is connected to the front second story and is not detailed as a dormer. The rear of this facade incorporates both the recent upstairs half -story addition and the projecting sunroom addition and stairs. (See Continuation Sheet Page 4) DPR 523L (1195) ;State of.Califorrna THe Resource`sAgencj% » '� DEPARTMENi� ,OFtPARKSAND }RECREATIONa;C ,! 7 CONTINUATION SHEET'�r� Trinomlal�� Page 4 of 12 Resource Name or #(Assigned by Recorder) 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga Recorded By: Leslie Dill and April Halberstadt Date: 2 -13 -2003 x Continuation Update Continued from P3a Description Page 3 Character - defining features of the exterior of the residence include: • Roof form, especially second floors at front corners and main front- and rear - gables. • Compact footprint with projecting areas • Centered porch with classical balcony on second floor • Siding materials • Palladian, ribbon and leaded front windows • Simple double -hung rear windows • Height of main floor (and associated crawl space /basement) • Greek key frieze board at front floor level • Plain frieze board at rear /eaves • Deep boxed eave detail • Roof pitch • Recessed porch at rear Interior The interior is in good condition with many original materials and features. Of particular note in the dining room is an exceptionally fine example of an arched Romanesque fireplace with integral mantel. The dining room also has built -in buffet area, other fireplaces retain their original tile and mantels - -such as the one in the south parlor with Ionic columns- -and the ceilings are coved plaster. The interior staircase retains its original features although physical evidence at the second story landing shows that changes were made to the floor plan. The wood casings and baseboards are Victorian in flavor, with bulls' eye blocks at the upper corners. The kitchen has been significantly altered at the interior including new cabinets and counters. Outbuildings Garage This three -car garage is of recent construction; however, it was built using materials and in a style to match the original house. It features a steep hipped roof with two front gables, a wide frieze below the boxed eaves, and horizontal lap siding. Shed This simple accessory structure is rectangular in plan and constructed of vertical board walls. It is built on a mudsill with a wooden floor resting on grade. The shed has a large door opening on the north elevation and a wood window to the west. Secondary Residence and Potting Shed This one -story residence has a possibly historic false -front elevation facing the east. If historic, the building has been extensively remodeled throughout; however, it is also possible that it was built from salvage. The north half of the front elevation includes a shed porch roof, a double door, and a pair of six - over -six windows. . To the south side of the front, a rambling potting shed has been added, seemingly over a period of time. It includes wood framing and a corrugated fiberglass roof. The rear of the house reveals the low- pitched roof, a concrete porch, and modern windows. The house has a mixture of V- groove horizontal siding and channel rustic siding. Pool Behind the house is a recent swimming pool landscaped with brick paving. Pond To the front of the house, off - center in the lawn area circled by the driveway, is a small pond, currently dry, with overgrown vegetation surrounding it. Horse Shed To the south of the circular driveway is a stable constructed of plywood and conventional framing. DPR 523L (1/95) Page 5 of 12 Resource Name or #(Assigned by Recorder) 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga Recorded By: Leslie Dill and April Halberstadt Date: 2 -13 -2003 X Continuation Update Continued from B10 Significance Page 2 foothills of the Santa Clara Valley and includes what is now the town of Saratoga as well as property in Cupertino and Campbell. In 1844, Jose§ Noriega ceded all of his interest in his rancho to Ignacio Alviso. In 1848, Ignacio Alviso died and his portion of the Quito grant was willed to his grandson, Manuel Alviso. In 1858, Jose? Ramon Arguello, his mother Soledad Arguello and business partner S. M. Mezes became possessors of the property. After California became a state in 1850, legitimate titles to the Mexican land grants had to be verified by the American courts. The claim for the Quito Rancho title was filed in the United States District Court in October of 1860. Early Ownership In 1861, this parcel was within a larger holding of approximately 70 acres and belonged to a person with the last name of Carney (Roads: 1861). The Saratoga -Los Gatos Road bisects this early tract of seventy acres that by 1876 was owned by Charles Alden (1876 County Atlas). The parcel appears to have been divided soon after, and a triangular parcel of 37 acres that contained the subject property was outlined on Brainard's map of 1888. This triangular parcel falls below the Saratoga -Los Gatos Road and is formed by the intersection of three roads: Three Oaks Way, Fruitvale Avenue and Saratoga -Los Gatos Road. The property was owned by Mrs. M. Arthur before 1888 and was then sold to an owner named Merriman (Brainard: 1888). The USGS map of the Santa Cruz quadrangle - surveyed in 1895 - shows a house and barn on the subject property. By 1903, the 37 -acre triangle was in the hands of San Francisco attorney, Albert Newell Drown. Around 1903, the Saratoga Road was widened to allow the construction of the new Peninsular Interurban Railway. The 37- acre parcel was divided, with 3 -acre lots fronting on the new trolley line into town. San Francisco residents William and Marcelline Sherman built their house on the subject property just after the 1906 earthquake. The original house was reportedly demolished to make room for a newer structure. The new house was centered on approximately ten acres fronting on Fruitvale Avenue. There was a prune orchard to the rear and sides of their property (Caswell Interview). Mr. Sherman was the manager of the Merchants Ice 6 Cold Storage Company, a cold- storage warehouse company on the San Francisco waterfront. (V. Garrod interview). The family maintained a residence in San Francisco (San Francisco Directories) but Marcelline Sherman and the boys spent much of their time in Saratoga. The two boys graduated from Saratoga elementary schools and Los Gatos High School. Marcelline Sherman served on the Saratoga School Board for many years, and at one time was the Clerk of the School Board. William Sherman died in 1940 and one of the Sherman's sons reportedly died in World War II. In 1945, just at the end of the War, Marcelline Sherman sold the subject property to Howard and Kathleen Brooks (Official Records B1275:P277). She then moved north to an adjoining property with a smaller house that had been the caretakers' home at one time. The Brooks family held the property a few years, and then sold the main house (subject property) on a two -acre parcel to the Caswell family in August of 1952 (Caswell interview). When the Caswell family moved to "Fair Oaks ", there were several large oak trees in front of the house. These trees have since been removed although large oaks are still standing on either side of the front yard and behind the house. The Caswell Family is still considered notable within the Saratoga community for their participation in the local art and music community; less known but also important are engineer Dwight Caswell's significant contributions to the telecommunications industry. Mr. Caswell received patents for his inventions; his most recent invention was awarded in 1984 for a controlled variable compression ratio piston for an internal combustion engine. Helen Caswell used the enclosed sun porch on the southwest corner of the house as an artist's studio. Many Saratoga residents have paintings executed by Helen Caswell during her long career as a portrait painter. A stained glass window she designed appears in the Sebastopol United Methodist Church. In addition, Helen Caswell's illustrations appear in more than a dozen books, primarily religious stories for children. The Caswell children were noted for their interest in musical theater and in music. Christopher Caswell toured internationally with musician Robin Williamson and has recorded a number of albums of traditional and Celtic music. Christopher is also an instrument maker specializing in Celtic harps. He currently lives in Sebastopol. Construction of Structure Building records are not currently available for this structure. The house was within the jurisdiction of Santa Clara County at the time of construction and a search of the records failed to locate the contractor's filings. The Santa Clara County Assessor's office has recorded 1906, as the date of construction, a date that is consistent with the style of the house and earlier reports. DPR 523L (1/95) 6 Page 6 of 12 Resource Name or # (Assigned byRecorder) 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga Recorded By: Leslie Dill and April Halberstadt Date: 2 -13 -2003 x Continuation Update Continued from B10 Significance Page 5 Discrepancies with published sources The subject property appears in the publication Saratoga's Heritage, a listing of local heritage structures. "Fair Oaks" is noted as being owned by William Sherman who is described as a police and fire chief in San Francisco. Mr. Sherman's occupation was verified by San Francisco City Directories as the manager of a cold storage warehouse, consistent with the recollections of local sources. There is no apparent documentation that William Sherman was formally associated with the police department or the fire department in either San Francisco or Saratoga. Source material for the information listed in Saratoga Heritage has not been retained. Significance The residence clearly possesses quality in its architectural design that makes it eligible for the California Register of Historic Resources under Criterion 3. With further study of the building in its broader neighborhood context, it may be determined that it possesses a level of design in relation to the region that would make it eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places under Criterion C for architectural significance. The history of the property does not indicate a level of significance that would make it eligible for listing in the California Register under Criteria 1 or 2 or eligible for listing in the National Register under Criteria A or B for association with significant personages, events, or patterns of development. Continued from B12 References Page 2 Brainard, H. A. 1888 Map of Saratoga City Directories 1870 - 1968, City of San Jose (Saratoga included) City of Saratoga, Heritage Preservation Commission Saratoga's Heritage: A Survey of Historic Resources, January 1993. Cooper, Mrs. George (Louise Garrod) Telephone interview, February 3, 2003. County of Santa Clara Deeds and Official Records School Tax Assessment Records c 1930's Great Register of Voters, 1890 Cunningham, Florence R. 1967 Saratoga's First Hundred Years. Fresno, CA, Panorama West Book. Garrod, R. V. 1962 Saratoga Story. Published by the author, Saratoga, CA. Garrod, Vince Personal Interview, January 25, 2003. Munro - Fraser 1881 History of Santa Clara County, California. San Francisco: Alley, Bowen & Co. Peck, Willys Personal Interview, January 25, 2003 San Josh Mercury 1896 Sunshine, Fruit and Flowers. Alfred Eaton, San Josh. Sawyer, Eugene 1922 History of Santa Clara County, California. Los Angeles, Historic Record Company. Quito Rancho Plat, filed in the County Recorder's Office Book A of Patents: Page 112. DPR 523L (1/95) State of California — The Resources Agency of 12 Resource Name or #(Assigned by Recorder) 15095 DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI # 6 Leslie Dill and April Halberstadt Date: 2 -13 -2003 CONTINUATION,.SHEET - Trinornia,l Page 7 of 12 Resource Name or #(Assigned by Recorder) 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga Recorded By: Leslie Dill and April Halberstadt Date: 2 -13 -2003 X Continuation _ Update Detail of Front Porch Ionic Columns, from the Southeast Photo by K. Oosterhous January 2003 DPR 523L (1/95) Detail of Siding, Greek Key Frieze, and Leaded Glass Window, from the Northeast Photograph by: K. Oosterhous January 2003 '�b qa.a,� i�..s10 � • f IM' �'d •a v. `1 ■R a Kul �rw Jam,,,, �' Sr s ti irl ,o-," �.� °TM: II! °� b,'• .�:�1' ��,' •� AS AN ,^mxF ^^�� uu..yJ� .;.� •..ma.,r•'�„ . -,sue"^ i'9 �, ±31 All 0t .'r 'r.: sit Vol t� ��o�?, xa.x n` wcer.,w.u• = »e.«�.�.:. K»a_. -' ...a:K..uv�� +•. -� Ps >�*bu s:w..x r�mxs.�•.sm'�.%sbIIR -�-x"a ��� ..aoa.,,w --� r•.�.- � ,� A � q :. N -�"g"°° d %s �. #�. ' S-'` Zf �''L a' 1 r .r r 4 � �"�� "" `��w.�"ra•..,s,.,c�.n. .: � 1 , Qdk AWE F no II3 C 7 , y^ `�� ,� ��if` * x �� jR d ActYm_ !re•3 as .x �- >3k a exa x wt r z a x M-4 IM5 41 yt fy. Mqj OWN- QA t.5' iz WA two AA .. �.., �:, �� ...�_..,,..auaaa..�,.:t,...��, ;g{•� T¥ �.:..� w:.w,,,„ � �.+p,,.— �.c•�r•.- »� -'�3- ',GWswa,a, � %�-�'� ����� '�: �--�' �'--- ''.'f¢4".aw>k� f�.uarn�� s• u., k � f � �`.:'':Yr „�•i.. 'Y' i:. ,FK' n5_ ,. ,iA'�i_.� .,.a,a .s _ 53...iysE . '@M: ?%i.�.: &�r�'4'� .,L `• Y '. " " <'•4'' _. State of California — The Resources Agency Primary # DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI # CONTINUATION SHEET Trinomial Page 9 of 12 Resource Name or # (Assigned by Recorder) 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga Recorded By: Leslie Dill and April Halberstadt Date: 2 -13 -2003 x Continuation _ Update DPR 523L (1/95) Detail of Rear Fagade showing Upper Level, Enclosed Porch, and Sunroom, from the Southwest Photograph by: K. Oosterhous January 2003 Photo of North Side, from the Northwest Photograph by: K. Oosterhous January 2003 Lgf. is r,: 've s � ra a:ry� ,fir � ..% ',., � �..' ' ` ,� ; 'l•r ' r � � �� 'r' �,p as �'t• 'l S eR t z` / � � •� r �, s s is s,�' � . f. let \ It M ��` � .............. 4j�A .Q• . 4k��`�j$1 O,,.... r•.�.'i: l�. �fe`. �.- _ 1f7 d`;�,tto`1o' '1 z s o-3»:• Ulm OR a> OAS ` Y h,qN '� >F Sy s $k ✓ two Imp Mo R, f ..Eu.•'( t q � ¢4 lti.t'r: s t�iY wit !a' Iit�e° win + 'i47;I � � ? .4 (4 9 � '� „s•,•� X1+1 a.�' Q .± 1 1 i v! aq r �r".°�e r i' 1 ti ♦ �" :ttii ��1 P 1• . Cr'.r � � t4. �r 't `d� �g'+'f �r ,9 ���i , 'tbt t� ♦.`� � d: �P i ' s2, y�' axi't d}+a. ►. �.a.. `a fib„ °,`�rl 7 A .�t 'a1"�}p { e A �) P �? eyiii�a.'P° �,e F r+. ': �,i r ♦ RIVAL gi1�a�� rxµ i'X • � R�.L:, "` .,' pia t {�A `OS;k 1 � �wra As; � $. 'AI F �� � �; may.. ��te a'+.. •d �t91�v� 4> y4r {(,�4 4 t!K �•�•3 � t r. i'!"*�y g`6 t "sA Wki�.�..ej;t ♦`� ! °y�+e�'t"t.l, :dw„ay S.m iy `°c L4. 'a 2 } x„) s y { F { + . "Not Au ply. xF v� Y �,¢, ": c:iq ? .. f t x 9_7 Awn �•��s # r i'�.' 0-0 (5 ?� r.ra�' �iS1• r +r" .� � r l 't,&,praF "s`�. � s � ,C. �gg xa �,W V Cy � ZA ffffffffffff F .tia •f `584.. � ��� a' 'X :� � �N�� f a w� ,4 � � 5.... � \CUa 3. '.. ,. *"`�.} :'t a .6'S'T 3� >•r.t ;Y 4 •'! J,a i BPS �F ,,,,..ee'','�} }�. '�'ie t R ea. t n° shJZ.y f �w., F .S( �• 4�`'�9 iz � r �, ,r a s' 6'!'y e' �..yp :t �'�� i f„m�•$be gsq�: rr'-,. a 8 sr r. s�., r.; .•£•• Ste° z a '°°' t QMY .._... ..... to Z .A •.wit e t ^ ,k , 0, . zy4 b ,r Ls i s.. ��'��`' }ernce yg °+;� kaa4y�f°.,✓,+S.gCas.r��. i ? '� a r `fit � 'dr * & � `t;'f°�.,q""'� �,.ay= .l'." i` 5 ; t•SEr' 'tt cti� <^tix `Fl:..ze t Bch 4 * i c i° �-` " .P a 't a � d a Sd —,cer _ � ,a'.�,• �'t¢r.i��3�k. •�a.`'."'2 y e..s �a, �''? ''' �� r 'r, v {' ' - ,t*,a,a` .t A�:r;;'` �uA, .�t•, r �'"%"ai •.r„a�...a` rx t }u x ,� �. �d P e >i''{;,TT ;u/+: t > rq :'.amt =q?';'�•+«+' d'',`. "''° y. r •� ,x f„; a't V a rs .. _ ..�..< .'� t. .... ? .�� .£ ..... SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR'S STANDARDS REVIEW FOR A PROPOSED REMODEL AND ADDITION PROJECT FOR THE HISTORIC CASWELL HOUSE "FAIR OAKS" Shukla Residence Project 15095 Fniitvale Avenue Saratoga, Santa Clara County California. For: Terry Martin, Architect Terry J. Martin Associates, AIA 45 East Main Street, Suite B Los Gatos, CA 95032 Prepared by: DILL DESIGN GKOuP 455 LOS GATOS BLVD #Z08 LOS GATOS. CALIrOKNIA (150-*)Z (4081 755 -5448 (408) X58 -544A rAX ddg @archistory.com Leslie A. G. Dill, Historic Architect October 24, 2003 uu OCT 2 8 2003 CITY OF SARATOGA 1'k4hA11NITV 11FVG? r' 2 INTRODUCTION Project Summary Terry Martin, Architect, retained Dill Design Group to conduct a Historic Resource Design Review of a proposed residential remodel and addition project at the Historic Caswell House, "Fair Oaks," located at 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga, California. Dill Design Group was asked to review the exterior elevations and site plan of the project to determine if the proposed project is in compliance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation (Standards). Qualifications Leslie A. G. Dill, Principal of the firm Dill Design Group, has a Master of Architecture with a certificate in Historic Preservation from the University of Virginia. She is licensed in California as an architect. Ms. Dill is listed with the Northwest Information Center of the California State Office of Historic Preservation as meeting the requirements to perform identification, evaluation, registration, and treatment activities within the professions of Historic Architect and Architectural Historian in compliance with slate and federal environmental laws. The Northwest Information Center utilizes the criteria of the National Park Service outlined in 36 CFR Part 61. Review Methodology Dill Design Group staff conducted a field visit of the subject property in February 2003. The site and surrounding context were examined. Characteristic features of the existing building were noted. Dill Design Group prepared a State of California Department of Parks and Recreation Form 523 (DPR523) dated February 13, 2003. Ms. Dill met with the architect, Terry Martin, and discussed the character - defining features of the historic resource and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation (Standards). Ms. Dill also reviewed an intermediate set of sketches and provided feedback. Progress Prints dated in anticipation of November 11, 2003 were provided to Dill Design Group for this report, and Ms. Dill evaluated the design according to the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation (Standards). The Standards are understood to be a common set of guidelines for the review of historic buildings and are used by many communities during the environmental review process to determine the potential impact of a project on an identified resource. Disclaimers The design for this project is currently in the development phase, and the final construction documents should be reviewed for consistency with this initial review. This report addresses the project plans in terms of historically compatible design. The consultant has not undertaken and will not undertake an evaluation or report on the structural conditions or other related safety hazards that might or might not exist at the site and building, and will not review the proposed project for structural soundness or other safety concerns. The consultant has not undertaken analysis of the site to evaluate the potential for subsurface resources. The design review is generally limited to the exterior of the building. PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Dill Design Group established the architectural significance of the Historic Caswell House in a DPR form recorded early in 2003. In the DPR form, it is noted that, "The residence clearly possesses quality in its architectural design that makes it eligible for the California Register of Historic Resources under Criterion 3. With further study of the building in its broader neighborhood context, it may be determined that it possesses a level of design in relation to the region that would make it eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places under Criterion C for architectural significance." PILL DESIGN GKOUF K3 Character- defining features of the exterior of the residence were listed in the DPR form. These include: • Roof form, especially second floors at front comers and main front- and rear- gables. • Compact footprint with projecting areas • Centered porch with classical balcony on second floor • Siding materials • Palladian, ribbon and leaded front windows • Simple double -hung rear windows • Height of main floor (and associated crawl space/basement) • Greek key frieze board at front floor level • Plain frieze board at rear /eaves • Deep boxed eave detail • Roof pitch • Recessed porch at rear Project Summary The proposed remodel and addition project, as presented in the most current set of architectural drawings noted above, includes some interior modifications, some repairs on the exterior, and some exterior modifications. Proposed on the exterior are the replacement of missing balusters at the front portico, repair of the existing brick chimney caps, addition of a small metal balcony with spiral stair off the dining room, replacement of a modem bay window with a more traditionally detailing bay window on the north side elevation, addition of shed dormers at the rear roof, replacement of existing windows in the rear nook, addition of low rear and side decks, addition of doors and windows on the south side elevation, and modification of the rear of the house in form, including removing some original material, some added material, and changing the rear entry configuration. SECRETARY'S STANDARD'S REVIEW: Executive Summary The proposed project appears consistent with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Analysis The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, originally published in 1977 and revised in 1990, include ten standards that present a recommended approach to repair, while preserving those portions or features that convey a resource's historical, cultural, or architectural values. The following is a list of the Standards and associated analysis regarding the Historic Caswell House "Fair Oaks" in Saratoga, California: 1. "A property will be used as it was historically or be given a new use that requires minimal change to its distinctive materials, features, spaces, and spatial relationships." Analysis: The use of this building and site do not change for this project. DILL PE316N GKOUF 2 2. "The historic character of a property shall be retained and preserved. The removal of historic materials or alteration of features, spaces, and spatial relationships that characterize a property will be avoided." Analysis: The removal of historic materials and alteration of spaces are generally avoided in this proposed design. The changes proposed to the rooflines, floor plan, and windows would not adversely alter the character of the property. The recessed rear porch will be modified, including the loss of some original wall material, but the replacement structure is in keeping with the original overall form of this feature. In particular because the porch had been modified over time, this change will not alter the character of the historic property. 3. "Each property will be recognized as a physical record of its time, place, and use. Changes that create a false sense of historical development, such as adding conjectural features or architectural elements from other historic properties, will not be undertaken." Analysis: The major modifications, such as the changes to the rear porch area, modifications to the front steps, and the modified bay window, are differentiated from the original in their materials and they are compatible to the original structure in form; therefore, they would not create a false sense of historical development. No other changes are proposed that might be mistaken for original features (See also Standards 6 and 9). 4. "Changes to a property that have acquired historic significance in their own right will be retained and preserved." Analysis: Although modifications to the main house have been identified, no proposed alterations will diminish the character as it changed over time. 5. "Distinctive materials, features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a property will be preserved." Analysis: Distinctive features, finishes, and construction techniques or examples of craftsmanship that characterize a property are generally preserved in this proposal. 6. "Deteriorated historic features will be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature will match the old in design, color, texture, and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features will be substantiated by documentary and physical evidence." Analysis: The project plans do not address the replacement of specific deteriorated features; however, the plans include general notes that convey the intent of this Standard. Replacement of the missing front portico balusters is based on physical evidence, and is in keeping with this Standard. The repair of the chimney caps is also based on physical evidence. DILL D1=S16N GKOUP 7. "Chemical or physical treatments, if appropriate, will be undertaken using the gentlest means possible. Treatments that cause damage to historic materials will not be used." Analysis: No harsh chemical or physical treatments seem to be proposed in this project. 8. "Archeological resources will be protected and preserved in place. If such resources must be disturbed, mitigation measures will be undertaken." Analysis: Archeological resources are not evaluated in this report. 9. "New additions, exterior alterations or related new construction will not destroy historic materials, features, and spatial relationships that characterize the property. The new work shall be differentiated from the old and will be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale and proportion, and massing to protect the integrity of the property and its environment." Analysis: The proposed changes to the front steps are in keeping with the character of the original front fagade, and do not replace a feature that characterizes the property. The modifications to the bay window on the north side remove only recent materials, and make the window more compatible with the historic resource. The form of the window itself differentiates the bay from the original house windows. The spatial changes at the rear porch are compatible with the original design of the building. The roof form remains, and the new portion of the walls will be differentiated with trim. The square column is adequately differentiated from the original round columns at the front of the house. The proposed changes to the windows and doors along the side and rear elevations, including the removal of the sunroom door facing east and the addition of the sunroom French doors facing west, do not impact the integrity of the resource; they are compatible with the significant character of the residence. The proposed porch additions are also in keeping with the original design of the house. They are proportionately modest in size and simple in detailing; therefore, they are subordinate to the original building. 10. "New additions and adjacent or related new construction will be undertaken in such a manner that, if removed in the future, the essential form and integrity of the historic property and its environment would be unimpaired." Analysis: Although some portion of exterior walls, roof, doors, and windows will be removed to build this proposal, the essential form and integrity of the historic property would not be lost in this project. DILL DESIGN GKUcP HISTORY OF THE HOUSE Conrfnued were being dispersed following the bombing of Pearl Harbor in 1941. It was a wet Christmas but the service men were grateful for a roof over their heads. Marcelline Sherman was awarded a medal by President Truman for her Red Cross work. She died just a few months ago at the age of 98, having been an important part of Saratoga's history for 53 years. She, sold Fair Oaks in 1945. Over the years, pieces of the property were sold for home sites until only two acres remained. Dwight and Helen Caswell purchased Fair Oaks in 1951. The upstairs consisted of one bath and the two front bedrooms, the remainder being unfinished. To accommodate their family they turned the unfinished portion of the upstairs into several bedrooms and a bath, adding the skylights also. Eventually the carriage house was made into living quarters and at present is occupied. A few years ago part of the basement was remodeled into an apartment for Mrs. Caswell's mother. The Caswells raised four sons and one daughter in the family home. Helen Caswell recounted, "I have been drawing as long as I can remember." But she didn't paint professionally until her fifth child was born. Dwight Caswell, an art critic, launched her painting career by offering one of her works to a gallery. Helen is known for her lovely, unposed oils of children in natural settings. As her own children reached the tender age of four, she taught each one to hold a paint brush, and by age seven, they were painting in oils. The children have developed diverse careers now, but all maintain an interest in the arts. As Dwight Caswell remarked, "We are a heterogeneous family." A new chapter is being recorded in the lives of the Caswell family. Dwight, Helen and two sons have moved to a Sonoma County farm — to build, to paint, to farm and more. %qu peAND GARDEN 320 W oge Lone. Los Goon C01140 o 95030 VILLAGE HOUSE serves distinctive luncheons in a delightful garden setting, Monday through Friday at 11:45 a.m. and 1:15 p.m. VILLAGE HOUSE is also available for wed- dings, receptions, bridge luncheons, group luncheons, and brunches. VILLAGE GARDEN adjoins the dining room and features Village House cookbook and recipe cards, houseplants, baskets and many unique gift items. VILLAGE HOUSE — 354-1040 VILLAGE GARDEN — 354 -5880 Staffed by MING QUONG SERVICE LEAGUE volunteers. AU proceeds benefit MING QUONG CHILDREN'S CENTER. HISTORY OF THE HOUSE The Caswell House, "Fair Oaks," was built in the early 1900s. It is an example of the colonial revival style, popular at the turn of the century. Visitors will notice the slender Ionic columns supporting the entrance porch, the milled moldings, denticular moldings and cove ceilings. Four fireplaces are embellished by trims of egg and dart and bead and real. The living room, dining room and entrance hall are connected by double pocket doors, which can be a plus when entertaining. They are prized by children when they put on plays and entertainments. The first and second floors con- tain 4525 square feet and the basement, 2725 square feet. In all, this home has 7251 square feet of floor space. - When Fair Oaks was built, it was part of a 35 -acre parcel bounded by Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga -Los Gatos Road and Three Oaks Way. An earlier house on this site is believed to have been destroyed by fire. As early as 1885 and as late as 1929, this property boasted thousands of fruit trees. It was in 1929 the William Sherman family moved from San Francisco to Saratoga. They purchased the acreage, house and outbuildings from the Harold Drown Estate for $25,000 (a bargain even though the structures were in disrepair). William Sherman was Chairman of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners. He also held the positions of Chief of Fire and Police in San Francisco before retiring to Saratoga. Mr. and Mrs. Sherman were both a credit to the community. Among other generous acts, during World War II they provided shelter in the carriage house for 30 Fort Ord soldiers who r3&A Page sfionsotcd Gy �k'ml•nit .c�mnit �rohrtfics HISTORY OF THE HOUSE Continued were being dispersed following the bombing of Pearl Harbor in 1941. It was a wet Christmas but the service men were grateful for a roof over their heads. Marcelline Sherman was awarded a medal by President Truman for her Red Cross work. She died just a few months ago at the age of 98, having been an important part of Saratoga's history for 53 years. She sold Fair Oaks in 1945. Over the years, pieces of the property were sold for home sites until only two acres remained. Dwight and Helen Caswell purchased Fair Oaks in 1951. The upstairs consisted of one bath and the two front bedrooms, the remainder being unfinished. To accommodate their family they turned the unfinished portion of the upstairs into several bedrooms and a bath, adding the skylights also. Eventually the carriage house was made into living quarters and at present is occupied. A few years ago part of the basement was remodeled into an apartment for Mrs. Caswell's mother. The Caswells raised four sons and one daughter in the family home. Helen Caswell recounted, "I have been drawing as long as I can remember." But she didn't paint professionally until her fifth child was born. Dwight Caswell, an art critic, launched her painting career by offering one of her works to a gallery. Helen is known for her lovely, unposed oils of children in natural settings. As her own children reached the tender age of four, she taught each one to hold a paint brush, and by age seven, they were painting in oils. The children have developed diverse careers now, but all maintain an interest in the arts. As Dwight Caswell remarked, "We are a heterogeneous family." A new chapter is being recorded in the lives of the .Caswell family. Dwight, Helen and two sons have moved to a Sonoma County farm — to build, to paint, to farm and more. ML WAND GARDEN Jso vooge Lane. Los Gaon CoMarro 950M VILLAGE HOUSE serves distinctive luncheons in a delightful garden setting, Monday through Friday, at 11:45 a.m. and 1:15 p.m. VILLAGE HOUSE is also available for wed- dings, receptions, bridge luncheons, group luncheons, and brunches. VILLAGE GARDEN adjoins the dining room and features Village House cookbook and recipe cards, houseplants, baskets and many unique gift items, VILLAGE HOUSE — 354 -1040 VILLAGE GARDEN — 354 -5880 Staffed by MING QUONG SERVICE LEAGUE volunteers. All proceeds benefit MING QUONG CHILDREN'S CENTER. 5 HISTORY OF THE HOUSE The Caswell House, "Fair Oaks," was built in the early 1900s. It is an example of the colonial revival style, popular at the turn of the century. Visitors will notice the slender Ionic columns supporting the entrance porch, the milled moldings, denticular moldings and cove ceilings. Four fireplaces are embellished by trims of egg and dart and bead and real. The living room, dining room and entrance hall are connected by double pocket doors, which can be a plus when entertaining. They are prized by children when they put on plays and entertainments. The first and second floors con- tain 4525 square feet and the basement, 2725 square feet. In all, this home has 7251 square'feet of floor space. - When Fair Oaks was built, it was part of a 35 -acre parcel bounded by Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga -Los Gatos Road and Three Oaks Way. An earlier house on this site is believed to have been destroyed by fire. As early as 1885 and as late as 1929, this property boasted thousands of fruit trees. It was in 1929 the William Sherman family moved from San Francisco to Saratoga. They purchased the acreage, house and outbuildings from the Harold Drown Estate for $25,000 (a bargain even though the structures were in disrepair). William Sherman was Chairman of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners. He also held the positions of Chief of Fire and Police in San Francisco before retiring to Saratoga. Mr. and Mrs. Sherman were both a credit to the community. Among other generous acts, during World War II they provided shelter in the carriage house for 30 Fort Ord soldiers who 3 • 9414 page s1.onsosrd Gq �k'mrnrr.c`moif �tohcrfies HISTORY OF THE HOUSE Confinued were being dispersed following the bombing of Pearl Harbor in 1941. It was a wet Christmas but the service men were grateful for a roof over their heads. Marcelline Sherman was awarded a medal by President Truman for her Red Cross work. She died just a few months ago at the age of 98, having been an important part of Saratoga's history for 53 years. She sold Fair Oaks in 1945. Over the years, pieces of the property were sold for home sites until only two acres remained. Dwight and Helen Caswell purchased Fair Oaks in 1951. The upstairs consisted of one bath and the two front bedrooms, the remainder being unfinished. To accommodate their family they turned the unfinished portion of the upstairs into several bedrooms and a bath, adding the skylights also. Eventually the carriage house was made into living quarters and at present is occupied. A few years ago part of the basement was remodeled into an apartment for Mrs. Caswell's mother. The Caswells raised four sons and one daughter in the family home. Helen Caswell recounted, "I have been drawing as long as I can remember." But she didn't paint professionally until her fifth child was born. Dwight Caswell, an art critic, launched her painting career by offering one of her works to a gallery. Helen is known for her lovely, unposed oils of children in natural settings. As her own children reached the tender age of four, she taught each one to hold a paint brush, and by age seven, they were painting in oils. The children have developed diverse careers now, but all maintain an interest in the arts. As Dwight Caswell remarked, "We are a heterogeneous family." A new chapter is being recorded in the lives of the Caswell family. Dwight, Helen and two sons have moved to a Sonoma County farm — to build, to paint, to farm and more. -ft�eA N D G A R D E N 320 VWOge lane. Las Gaul Calft 050.'10 VILLAGE HOUSE serves distinctive luncheons in a delightful garden setting, Monday through Fridav at 11:45 a.m. and 1:15 p.m. VILLAGE HOUSE is also available for wed- dings, receptions, bridge luncheons, group luncheons, and brunches. VILLAGE GARDEN adjoins the dining room and features Village House cookbook and recipe cards, houseplants, baskets and many unique gift items. VILLAGE HOUSE — 354 -1040 VILLAGE GARDEN — 354 -5880 Stiffed by MING QUONG SERVICE LEAGUE volunteers. , All proceeds benefit MING QUONG CHILDREN'S CENTER. W HISTORY OF THE HOUSE The Caswell House, "Fair Oaks," was built in the early 1900s. It is an example of the colonial revival style, popular at the turn of the century. Visitors will notice the slender Ionic columns supporting the entrance porch, the milled moldings, denticular moldings and cove ceilings. Four fireplaces are embellished by trims of egg and dart and bead and real. The living room, dining room and entrance hall are connected by double pocket doors, which can be a plus when entertaining. They are prized by children when they put on plays and entertainments. The first and second floors con- tain 4525 square feet and the basement, 2725 square feet. In all, this home has 7251 square feet of floor space. - When Fair Oaks was built, it was part of a 35 -acre parcel bounded by Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga -Los Gatos Road and Three Oaks Way. An earlier house on this site is believed to have been destroyed by fire. As early as 1885 and as late as 1929, this property boasted thousands of fruit trees. It was in 1929 the William Sherman family moved from San Francisco to Saratoga. They purchased the acreage, house and outbuildings from the Harold Drown Estate for $25,000 (a bargain even though the structures were in disrepair). William Sherman was Chairman of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners. He also held the positions of Chief of Fire and Police in San Francisco before retiring to Saratoga. Mr. and Mrs. Sherman were both a credit to the community. Among other generous acts, during World War II they provided shelter in the carriage house for 30 Fort Ord soldiers who r3&A pa/geiponiocedGy �rliml•nit =`mn /I �ti�(2t tfi[i THE CASWELL HOUSE Floor Plan 1 Encore! Encore! Boutique ■ 27 . 25 24 26 I 99h Page s,&no -J ry 94is Page tPohioted Gy 'A'.. J u. eR06 E D. cyi4S 7 C44L. V `VVlffl.. #iu fLy i THE CASWELL DOUSE Floor Plan 1 Encore! Encore! Boutique 27 • 25 24 26 I `Pubi page tponioud fig I `-Mi pagr ipokioaed Gq At. 6 Au. eRo&tt 13. cYi4s 6 7 efli. E+ c4fvi. (Wiffiam Auf-y HISTORY OF THE HOUSE Continued were being dispersed following the bombing of Pearl Harbor in 1941. It was a wet Christmas but the service men were grateful for a roof over their heads. Marcelline Sherman was awarded a medal by President Truman for her Red Cross work. She died just a few months ago at the age of 98, having been an important part of Saratoga's history for 53 years. She sold Fair Oaks in 1945. Over the years, pieces of the property were sold for home sites until only two acres remained. Dwight and Helen Caswell purchased Fair Oaks in 1951. The upstairs consisted of one bath and the two front bedrooms, the remainder being unfinished. To accommodate their family they turned the unfinished portion of the upstairs into several bedrooms and a bath, adding the skylights also. Eventually the carriage house was made into living quarters and at present is occupied. A few years ago part of the basement was remodeled into an apartment for Mrs.. Caswell's mother. The Caswells raised four sons and one daughter in the family home. Helen Caswell recounted, "I have been drawing as long as I can remember." But she didn't paint professionally until her fifth child was born. Dwight Caswell, an art critic, launched her painting career by offering one of her works to a gallery. Helen is known for her lovely, unposed oils of children in natural settings. As her own children reached the tender age of four, she taught each one to hold a paint brush, and by age seven, they were painting in oils. The children have developed diverse careers now, but all maintain an interest in the arts. As Dwight Caswell remarked, "We are a heterogeneous family." A new chapter is being recorded in the lives of the Caswell family. Dwight, Helen and two sons have moved to a Sonoma County farm — to build, to paint, to farm and more. VILL A N D G A R D E NW 320 VN1oge lone. Los Go", CnlAartio 05030 VILLAGE HOUSE serves distinctive luncheons in a delightful garden setting, Monday through Friday at 11:45 a.m. and 1:15 P.M. VILLAGE HOUSE is also available for wed- dings, receptions, bridge luncheons, group luncheons, and brunches. VILLAGE GARDEN adjoins the dining room and features Village House cookbook and recipe cards, houseplants, baskets and many unique gift items. VILLAGE HOUSE — 354.1040 VILLAGE GARDEN — 354 -5880 Staffed by MING QUONG SERVICE LEAGUE volunteers. All proceeds benefit MING QUONG CHILDREN'S CENTER. HISTORY OF THE HOUSE The Caswell House, "Fair Oaks," was built in the early 1900s. It is an example of the colonial revival style, popular at the turn of the century. Visitors will notice the slender Ionic columns supporting the entrance porch, the milled moldings, denticular moldings and cove ceilings. Four fireplaces are embellished by trims of egg and dart and bead and real. The living room, dining room and entrance hall are connected by double pocket doors, which can be a plus when entertaining. They are prized by children when they put on plays and entertainments. The first and second floors con- tain 4525 square feet and the basement, 2725 square feet. In all, this home has 7251 square feet of floor space. When Fair Oaks was built, it was part of a 35 -acre parcel bounded by Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga -Los Gatos Road and Three Oaks Way. An earlier house on this site is believed to have been destroyed by fire. As early as 1885 and as late as 1929, this property boasted thousands of fruit trees. It was in 1929 the William Sherman family moved from San Francisco to Saratoga. They purchased the acreage, house and outbuildings from the Harold Drown Estate for $25,000 (a bargain even though the structures were in disrepair). William Sherman was Chairman of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners. He also held the positions of Chief of Fire and Police in San Francisco before retiring to Saratoga. Mr. and Mrs. Sherman were both a credit to the community. Among other generous acts, during World War II they provided shelter in the carriage house for 30 Fort Qrd soldiers who 3 . SF4L page saonsotPCd Cy �'.mfnf��`ma�C �tu(sctfici SHUKLA RESIDENCE 15095 Fruitvale Avenue, Saratoga, CA 95070 CONSULTANTS VICINITY MAP PROJECT DATA SHEET INDEX ARCHITECT: OWNERS: - — �• I... _., �• SITE LOCATION: TERRY MARTIN ARCHITECTS RAMA & MINNIE %UKLA 1■ 1 15096 FAV<TVALE AVE NUE SARATDGl� ca 95070 Art COVER SHEET AND PROJECT DATA 45 E. MAIN STREET, SUITE B LOS GATOS, CA 95030 19493 BURGUNDY" SARATOGA, CA 95070 r,— �. - -) X = oa -p! ak J :„.- ..,. i BU DING OCCUPANCY GROUPS: R-1, SINGE FAMILY RESIDENCE A-2 A-3 SITE PLAN, TOPO, TREES (E) LOWER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN (408) 395 -8016 (408) 867 -9582 L y TYPE OF CONSTRUCTK t V-N (NON- SPWNKLEREO) A-4 (E) MAN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN (408) 395 -5732 (FAX) ; = n" R s �t. { ' <1 )- , ~ ` STORIES. TWO STORY A-5 (E) UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN STRUCTURAL OJ ENGINEERS & ASSOCIATES BUILDER: DEMATTEI CONSTRUCTION o �+�..: -- _ a APN#: ZONING: 397 -19-010 R- 1- 40,000 A-6 (E) ROOF P(JW 480 ST. JOHN STREET, SUITE 220 1794 THE ALAMEDA ' �, (� sh ' LOT AREA 83,454.21 S F. (1.91 Ae es) A 7 N LOWER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN ( ) PLEASANTON, CA 94566 SAN JOSE, CA 95123 .� ` �3 .� + ' FAR.: 6,640 S.F. MAX A-8 (N) MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN (925) 846 -9429 (408) 295 -7516 •�•+rc _ A1 o / ',a •" 4 AVERAGE SITE SLOPE: _ LEVEL A-9 (N) UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN (925) 846 -9653 (FAX) (408) 295 -6589 (FAX) s. %, e ' YEARS A-10 (N) ROOF PLAN AGE OF RESMENCE: APPROX. 97 TOPO: TITLE 24 ENERGY CONSULTANT: ° erg,= -� _ x,0,5 � /�� s ¢ / ' APPLICABLE CODES" 79 %CBG 1997 UBC, IDIC, IPC, Atm19 %1ffC, AS AMENDED BY. 7*i l (E) FRONT 8 RIGHT ELEVATIONS LEA & SUNG ENGINEERING, INC 2495 INDUSTRIAL PARKWAY WEST FRANK R. LANM1CC1 21 N. HARRISON AVE. _ ° . �' THE STATE OF CN FORWA AND LOCAL JUWSWCTI4N AppUGgBLE TO THS PROJECT. ARE A 12 (E) REAR &LEFT ELEVATIONS HAYWARD, CA 94545 CAMPBELL, CA 95008 - o " DATA A-13 (N) FRONT & RKafT ELEVATIONS (510) 887�{I86 (408) 886 -1620 = . g.� N BuILODNG sF.: A-14 (N) REAR & IFFT ELEVATIONS (510) 887-3019 (FAX) (408) 886 -6832 (FAX) (E) LOWER LEV,l (N) LOWER LEVEL: + 2,858-0 S.F. MAIN Hong. + 14.0 S.F. GARAGE: + 2,661.0 S.F. 688.0 S.F. A-15 CROSS SECTIONS _ —z p — a r I + A -16 (E) GARAGE FLOOR AND ROOF PLANS (E) MAIN LEVEL: +2,643.0 S.F. GUEST HOUSE + 7,505.0 S.F. . (N) MAIM LEVEL- + 21.0 S.F. PoT11NG SHED #7: + 273.0 S.F. A-17 (N) & (E) GUEST HOUSE FLOOR AND (E) ROOF PLANS SCOPE OF WORK (E)�� - 60.0 S.F. POTTING SHED #Z: + 41.0 S.F, BARft + 400.0 S.F. (E) UPPER LEVEL• +2,014.0 S.F. CONCRETE DRIVEWAY: + 11,984.0 S.F. Remodel and add minimal Square footage to Lower and Main Levels. Lower a CONCRETE PATHWAYS + 1,437.0 S.F. - portion of the lower level to achieve a 9' -0" ceiling height Re -work front entry Stairs. Add balcony to the south aide of house and a small sitting wall, with TOTAL LIVING ARENA 7,490.0 S.F. POOL DECKING + 1,525.0 S.F. . access to the lower leveL Add an exterior metal spiral staircase and small POCUHDT TUBJ POND: + 1,382.0 S.F. landing Off of the (E) Dining Room. Remove (E) exterior rear stairs. Realocate (E) GARAGE: + 688.0 S.F. STARS/ LANDING& + 457D S.F. . Some square footage on the Main L.eveL Add a small Sluing wall with access (E) GUEST HOUSE +1,2614 S.F. BRICK PATHWAYS + 897.0 S.F. to the lower level and add a balcony off of the Great Room with stairs to grade. _ Relocate (1E) garage to allow applicable access to the (M Balcony. Remodel (E) POTTING SHED 01: + 273.0 S.F. the interior portion of the Guest House. Repair dry-rot as required. (E) POTTING SHED 02: + 41.0 S.F. TOTAL SF.: 23,250.0 S.F. . . (E) BARN + 400.0 S.F. MAX ALLOWABLE DeERVIOUS: 29,069.0 S.F. . TOTAL &xLDING SF.: 10.7 53.0 SF. IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE Ft.0oRA'E^wn° WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS MAIN HOUSE: + 4,618.0 S.F. pp n U L I 2 2003 03 OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: GARAGE: + 688.0 S.F. . GUEST HOUSE, +1,261-0 S.F. FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT POTnNG SHED #1: + 2734 S.F. CITY OF SARATOGA SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR R THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE POTTING SHED #Z BARN, + 41.0 S.F. *e> �T lTl1lTN T)FIl FT nom" �- + 400.0 S.F. • TOTAL S.F-- 7,281.0 S.F. MAX ALLOWABLE FAR.: 6,840.0 S.F. - IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - 'REPLACE IT WITH LIKE I30 ' 30' I PARCEL 1 I RECORD OF SURVEY PARCEL 2 BOOK 178 OF MAPS, AT PAGE 31 � IZ \ � g L LAND OF i_ I X- p MCGUIRE EASE 472.9r .f1Y� I a S-0` _ (• (3)14 O'OAK 6B119f -' - ON N • Wooe Fina i \40'duc > wmd 'TAEE ,ma• war wan - n.a S _ • W 31 DU S A — — — wan• \ _� 369191 fth'- - -- - -- -- - - -- - -- -- -- a 24 ' rtE (E) (1fE STORY r4 O�IEAY ERCC7( \ 1p1^ GUEST HO116E tats. R--k d R— (E) 60' -0. FF. - 103.5' dea L mtvete w \ 43'A UADet Lewd aaatvdale widen 9 O PLANTER LLJ (2)6 • W Maki Iced 45 ,� \ \ (2)) • Q 8 R—mbay _ — .a \ - T1EE•I g W j WOOD 7-11M 12'TREE J I DECK I� Illilt TWOSTpfI uIi ewa \ 1 TtmE• w/ HpISE tL •I CRAIG • 1 .5' RRIOG , W " can D— (E) A.AIrrFR Palo \ ` 14 -TREE taerretA — 1 is- TREE• " OEM 2/ a Mr- s� 1 20' I 30' w, U 01) tarlvece m Carly TRACT # 3093 MONTECITO GLEN BOOK 158 OF MAPS AT PAGE 6 SITE PLAN O 10 20 40 SCALE: 1" - 20' �. aR — OVF3REAR POWER U E . Move W awl-Rom JOINT POSE O QTY ANCHOR O m R.ECrRIC METER y,y WATER VALVE p w r5'� WocA ivte �nal, ' °4 xioc� �? v a. LANDS OF SHUKLA CONCRETE DMEWAY TREE: TYPE AID SUE AS MOOD 9R0C a'n i i i i i �. (E) &RRAQ FS- 107.17' I � ��' 1.9 ACRES wan 1 � � , ° > 5'P Chii l utFw� / 7'11EE1� I �, • 52'O/Yt - SfORnFE BENCHMARK TOP OF FAE NY01WCf - - -_ l O � _ __ -_ __ - -• - , ( 'm Pouliot; _'_•_= -_ == - m a\ ..n _ __ __ Fran ywd w . a,- - WaaU Finaa 48'TiEE � - pp FLEW 96.2 - H \ • rm,. - \ llt EVV \ 1 lali FVO OAK LANDS OF PATKA — — LOT 2 1 $ I TRACT # 3093 MONTECITO GLEN BOOK 158 OF MAPS AT PAGE 6 SITE PLAN O 10 20 40 SCALE: 1" - 20' o ,uti u —VY x ll.l c .. E < NJ6LL� � f } Lu +J {.j C O LEGEND aR — OVF3REAR POWER U E CONCRETE W awl-Rom JOINT POSE O QTY ANCHOR O m R.ECrRIC METER y,y WATER VALVE p w WAM METER TX FJM HYDRANT O SANITARY SEWER CLEAN -OUT xioc� SPDTGRAOE e eeHOEAAaK W TREE TREE: TYPE AID SUE AS MOOD o ,uti u —VY x ll.l c .. E < NJ6LL� � f } Lu +J {.j C O U W o >° O O O O aA i O � a0c'n ISM r� x 5 i i i i i o ,uti u —VY x ll.l c .. E < NJ6LL� � f } Lu +J {.j C O Data 8!22/03 Ploject 002063 Sole: 1 • -1'-0' . OrAlYrl by. SEMM PD Sheet HITS SrM PLAN A -2 U W o >° O O O O aA O � a0c'n ISM r� x 5 Data 8!22/03 Ploject 002063 Sole: 1 • -1'-0' . OrAlYrl by. SEMM PD Sheet HITS SrM PLAN A -2 U W o >° aA O � a0c'n ISM r� x Data 8!22/03 Ploject 002063 Sole: 1 • -1'-0' . OrAlYrl by. SEMM PD Sheet HITS SrM PLAN A -2 .T.I ! S'Io AFF. !"0/ 1. MAiNUVEL FLOOR PLAN Note: AG dbrwniorm we to be add Verified i- --a r Ab- L__J mogw� 2 a t uj mueO1n .qn �I Q r 9ooKE a t1J H N_ 4 o 0 U ea (E) 2810 (E) zero zalo _ a s !S'10 AfF. lS10 AFF. !6'S Af3. ® !6'S AFF. Q i i bra � (E) 2010 ai ! C2' AfF s a�i o '� G kn rtq lE) 21ie c of rtq ENTRANCE o WORK AREA 9, =� (E) 2M ! re AFF rtq LOWER LEVEL _ AREA 7' CEILING m2ele \ STORAGE II III it III 11 - III � I III II II � I � STORAGE ROOM 1 0 (El 3eei STORAGE ROOM 3 e aq (E) zm ic c iR • m2 (E) 2uo (q 2610 (E) 1010 oI I Iil$I I I I I I s o — LIJILL� L------- - - - - -J ! S'Io AFF. !"0/ 1. MAiNUVEL FLOOR PLAN Note: AG dbrwniorm we to be add Verified i- --a r Ab- L__J mogw� 2 a t uj mueO1n .qn �I Q r 9ooKE a t1J H N_ 4 o 0 U ea W v gs a s 0Q1N Q i i bra � U � ai w tu v, s a�i o '� G kn W v 0Q1N Q bra � U � ai w tu v, ' a�i o '� G kn Date: 9/22/03 Project u 02063 Sdr. 114' -i'-W Ora1En by. SENM Sheet tftbw LOWER LEVII. FLOOR PLAN A -3 (E) MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN N cb,* im a to be Fidel Verified mo�nN ff LU LU o W F- '5 . 4-J ca CD v 3BS �4xS W U z A ,; d� �v Uo 9 x%nCn Date. 8/22/03 Ro}xt 002063 cO 0 Drawn bi. S 3 5 En S °a W U z A ,; d� �v Uo 9 x%nCn Date. 8/22/03 Ro}xt 002063 Salt 1/4' -1'-0' Drawn bi. SEMM Sheet Me (E) MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN A-4 02"s m 2636 3 I TZ4M (E) 24M 04'kW f.• — , sr (E) UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN NOW AD dn*ESfons are to be ReW Vern*d (E) an _07 3'.s' tOr I 0 C) 3- 3'� 4 PULE K �—n ACCM to CO T� pbh CL.5" 2068 for I tar ru cr MASTER SLUTE c. r BEDROOM 4 (E) Pitdwd —KN mzm ZM narWq 8• -1 (noes not m 15--o-) r4 CLOSET L F—I F BATHROOM (E) 2m 8• -1 • caeWwmv 9 (E) zi CLos" w L U 1 L ce&Q t5 Z BEDROOM 3 0 BEDROOM 2 T-8- Cie —DN 9--V C.&V V-0'cwe a. iE 7' 7- CeWV CE) (E) M. (E) evv I m evr (E) UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN NOW AD dn*ESfons are to be ReW Vern*d rl- �III!!il !,ii III �- l I L i_ (E) ROOF PLAN LIJ1L.1�__� I L---== - - - - -- j F Tr! 4T1- i Iilil!!lil! Ij IIII!!III!I !! I!Illill!!I Ly j I L �I ! Ll_J WALL LEGEND UPPER LEVEL WALLS WM LEVEL WALLS m o m hem N ei Q V m m i L S- o -a-iIIl _ -i - <Q ErW e w co ° o te4 Project 902063 Sdc 1/4' -l`-O' Dr by. SEAM I L---== - - - - -- j F Tr! 4T1- i Iilil!!lil! Ij IIII!!III!I !! I!Illill!!I Ly j I L �I ! Ll_J WALL LEGEND UPPER LEVEL WALLS WM LEVEL WALLS m o m hem N ei Q V m m i L S- o -a-iIIl _ -i - <Q ErW e w co ° o te4 W U '0QN 0 o o, d' E O a� o V] Date 8/22/03 Project 902063 Sdc 1/4' -l`-O' Dr by. SEAM � a n � W U '0QN 0 o o, d' E O a� o V] Date 8/22/03 Project 902063 Sdc 1/4' -l`-O' Dr by. SEAM See[ tlUe: (E) ROOF PLAN A -6 rv. I &J 1; \O / \O t ft Wy gRYq \v/ ---- I—IL -- F 3,•a I� - --JI LLB— — (N) LOWER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN -A `(E B*' - — - — - — - — - — - — - IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE (E) LOWER LEVEL 2,858 Sf. (N) LOWER LEVEL 14 S.F. IR) LOWER LEVEL - S.S,F. (6J Rov m d 6cSVb m a�» U. mm. A 9'P Gid TOTAL. 2,872 S.F. WALL LEGEND NEW WALLS E)BSTM WAILS — — — WALLS TO BE REMOVED allmrq AEew PRY. d_ � I = �S10 AFJ. A.F. 5'10 F. l6a AFF. I ® PBS AFi. (E)2030 - I Ab° ! 62' AJF (E) 2"S C Dan I (D Fw.d Abv,e (O ZUa I u 6 �p i o1 MUSIC ROOM zase c ENTRANCE � s � Co sy ® ® I ® IN 6'-8' Ceig -- I m zmo ! a2 AFF w+m STORAGE ' aesa - T -0• CalbV I (�zma PAT10 A% zees wmy c§ H -- T- — — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - - - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — — arm I BEDROOM #4 L�md— sm,v wr 9-'celft ............. . I . I � �— —i I ,� I �S - E -9' ' -lo• 4' ❑ i\rl I Ir— �i $_ Aye °�IJ .' 1 / II I °Iwo l— M zSFS� II Fab�w ; s O9 wr II LoAerBau I 3 ------ �- - - -- (q , (Q uc3N g' -0'CBBtg � . � I � � T GUEST SUITE I I I 00 R-0— FAMILY ROOM h £ I (E) 7'-0" cea y I ( I 9W-0- lr Cevg OO zees 7 � I I ( 7x ro & r M) ! *1 II i W/g .aA.a ° m c.. I I I (E)�m ou zaaa t§ II I g E) �� PW- zca � :5 I - -- --- - - - - -J =s° &J 1; \O / \O t ft Wy gRYq \v/ ---- I—IL -- F 3,•a I� - --JI LLB— — (N) LOWER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN -A `(E B*' - — - — - — - — - — - — - IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE (E) LOWER LEVEL 2,858 Sf. (N) LOWER LEVEL 14 S.F. IR) LOWER LEVEL - S.S,F. (6J Rov m d 6cSVb m a�» U. mm. A 9'P Gid TOTAL. 2,872 S.F. WALL LEGEND NEW WALLS E)BSTM WAILS — — — WALLS TO BE REMOVED 63'�l 11.5' nn wood Dsd"$IA . Lower Porch L L— - ON 3 Ups! upper as• � 115•M Porch I I R) 2659 I (r) 2659 ! r'6 ArF. PT6 AFF. (E) M 206• —• — ' 4tn (E)2,02,0 y! P7ti AfF. (E) (E) 2666 I I I I I a r LIVING R DINING ROOM [ (E) 10• -6- (E} 10'-6' CeLgs I I II I II za6s • radl ,apdtad ' Pell — — potiel a� I fOSUa- — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - (' 1e.etv.! HALL • (E) 10•-6, Cel45e D 2066 — e1•E.1 — — m�L,�— — dot•ib Fie/ GREAT ROOM 2 — L el (E) 10'6• Calsgs 3 �! wsma"'"y c — mp I !� 6 (E) W., POWDER Ab S— Dt- [ip DOOM �FkWi— ... . I ... I; Pam.ldwr: L I" - D noA.d. n.ee1 (E) rs drs COVERED PORCH ,7•m SN! (E) 8' -S• CeTv,p9 t raise to 10'-6' I 1 (N) ° h�lA 6s ewP CsmT (b wE 2,x510 G911 1q. w, I7tL z +so wet ear �T�i).1rAeledd © ~ _3LI -j1 L - wwaDaltr — •aww — OD 3060 brdauoq trasan woe �— — Q)2,021. l T6 AfI-- yi og )OM Cefir,ps o s g5S �ad a COVERED oN i PORCH Wass Dee. -e St- elnaa Stage n thm tal Eae�a � a,' m a m bA dc. drat OY 4' �. rn net Ota.IU>n 0' � ne (Wi Vw ov.IRLSas (s'wirY Im.Yte rtpiso�) ItFRA� DOSre1G wi Sea;tt Swa: wRM ' O O ! TS AFF. I _ rEwIQ EIISIe1G wi sric wm,l oN 6,1 D� M/[' weDOw (1) 2659 ! TS Ari. ! T6 AFJ HOME OFFICE 5K ! 7T AfF. Fldae 1 � KITCHEN ( E lq't'S PA 10'{' Ce (E) 10•-6• Cef&gs (E) (E) a 3 -- .? I 002659 — (E) I 1 11 T r- 1_— `� — IWr (eJ "oP x6 tb - (E) N12668 h wood Dsd"$IA . Lower Porch L L— - ON 3 Ups! upper as• � 115•M Porch I I R) 2659 I (r) 2659 ! r'6 ArF. PT6 AFF. (E) M 206• —• — ' 4tn (E)2,02,0 y! P7ti AfF. (E) (E) 2666 I I I I I a r LIVING R DINING ROOM [ (E) 10• -6- (E} 10'-6' CeLgs I I II I II za6s • radl ,apdtad ' Pell — — potiel a� I fOSUa- — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - — - (' 1e.etv.! HALL • (E) 10•-6, Cel45e D 2066 — e1•E.1 — — m�L,�— — dot•ib Fie/ GREAT ROOM 2 — L el (E) 10'6• Calsgs 3 �! wsma"'"y c — mp I !� 6 (E) W., POWDER Ab S— Dt- [ip DOOM �FkWi— ... . I ... I; Pam.ldwr: L I" - D noA.d. n.ee1 (E) rs drs COVERED PORCH ,7•m SN! (E) 8' -S• CeTv,p9 t raise to 10'-6' I 1 (N) ° h�lA 6s ewP CsmT (b wE 2,x510 G911 1q. w, I7tL z +so wet ear �T�i).1rAeledd © ~ _3LI -j1 L - wwaDaltr — •aww — OD 3060 brdauoq trasan woe �— — Q)2,021. l T6 AfI-- yi og )OM Cefir,ps o s g5S �ad a COVERED oN i PORCH Wass Dee. -e St- elnaa Stage 122 4li-J c O O 1 I _ V LL. H HOME OFFICE 5K 6 (E) 10' -6' Cdbxjs � � ; a 3 .? 6.eep6! - (E) N12668 rr ro. • ra,dl q l• Sep OJ 2656 (E) 3060 R7 3060 i I (E) f3akaq CE) tray // \ I \ T 7 1 it- I-ri -i - - - -- S i le I I I I 9 ,0 11 ,z 13 1, ,5 I � . I I i I 1 ffff fS Q C O 4 % E < •� m 4li-J c O O 1 4 C V u z 5K U :7QN �aii N Ed' Date 0/22/03 P-^t: ! 02063 Sr�c 1/4•�1'�!• Dann trl so4h% PD I (E) MAN LEVEL 2.643 S.F. Sheet ti1C (N) MAN LEVEL 21 S.F. �(R) W, l0 i..ovn m (10 arovn,P..) S.F. 1 IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE TarAl S.F. MAIN (A �l WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS LLNEL FLOOR (N) MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS_ WALL LEGEND PLAN FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR R NEW WALLS THIRD - REPLACE R WITH LIKE 00STM WALLS — — — — — WALLS TO BE REI,UW A -8 O O O O e O 5K g� � ; a U :7QN �aii N Ed' Date 0/22/03 P-^t: ! 02063 Sr�c 1/4•�1'�!• Dann trl so4h% PD I (E) MAN LEVEL 2.643 S.F. Sheet ti1C (N) MAN LEVEL 21 S.F. �(R) W, l0 i..ovn m (10 arovn,P..) S.F. 1 IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE TarAl S.F. MAIN (A �l WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS LLNEL FLOOR (N) MAIN LEVEL FLOOR PLAN OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS_ WALL LEGEND PLAN FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR R NEW WALLS THIRD - REPLACE R WITH LIKE 00STM WALLS — — — — — WALLS TO BE REI,UW A -8 —T- - -- ��— via I I :,T" .zvr I I I �- I IL — —JI i (N) UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN " II ,y! ST ,v ST 11 11 � II I I IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE (E) LIVER LEVEL 2.014 S.F. WALL LEGEND NEW WALLS EXISTING WALLS — — — — — — WALLS TO BE PB49VM mo imp Q � m �l Q L Si E W } LLL f'- i-J c :�>se Ro)ect 0 02063 0008 1/4• -11a- Orwsn by. SEw+, PD s s 3 7g - _ — — — — _ SITTING Aerie �m s—d c b9 1 Ce&V Vass emcee(0 : W10 (m Ya' I I (FJ Y i \ / Tapp x I I Tape a 'k b� 1mue Too=k— I I Teo P.r e I (Elsr s. c ° L I I a) te66 — — — — E—d (E) T 2- s -.::: - rmr / BEDROO�M�3 \ �— — — — — — �� (q re• I R 6. 3' G y e �v / C (Goes not erased 15'-0-) P.f I �� =� zsce oK(9 \ I vneo.. (Q z a a . , pt r 00 sore \ IV I Lvm" mom -- - - - — Tn -- - - -- — — - 11 gin" n rT�I l'— I =' -sue`__ �e, I_ 3.A, . -.. es• o�a.a:.a 1 1 1 1 1 1 I.I I I I I I I _— _— _— _— _— _— _ —_ '� - -- —_� — —�� °"° - - _— Tr ,_ J (,. — _— _ —_ e' —_ —_ -„m — -t•c"a 9. — - rt- rt- I------- ;— i- h- 1- -1 -1-T — -- I it �... '" IIIIII I I I I I I IIIIIIII I I I I I I I I I �. 1Li U11L11 a sr I eemme (� zone r� ,i Closet o °'� I r (s`a° ; — — sson /p�� 1 W• �� jjp1' 3 F i j J - I F. Master t „ u BEDROOM 2 I c� I I I . � W• s,e.a.En - �r - -� 13 rTHROOM 8'- 1•Ce,Tog � 91-01 Cam t w/ �:. I I\ GD .. --I . err ace- • ce• a qe• s e'e' i uee o�, — — — — -- — se. I —se.i I4 I roe+e,.w.ea I I I �- I IL — —JI i (N) UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN " II ,y! ST ,v ST 11 11 � II I I IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE (E) LIVER LEVEL 2.014 S.F. WALL LEGEND NEW WALLS EXISTING WALLS — — — — — — WALLS TO BE PB49VM mo imp Q � m �l Q L Si E W } LLL f'- i-J c :�>se W W O > N b a w a�rn Puce: 8/22/03 Ro)ect 0 02063 0008 1/4• -11a- Orwsn by. SEw+, PD s s 3 7g a W W O > N b a w a�rn Puce: 8/22/03 Ro)ect 0 02063 sdc 1/4• -11a- Orwsn by. SEw+, PD Sheet mk: UPPER LEVEL FLOOR PLAN A -9 -J I (M) Shd D— N. kk M | | | -J I (M) Shd D— N. kk M it E) RIDGE x | x |{ U | x |/| x | || x | U | U | x ||| || | /| | o / x |�| x '| x | / 1L — — — — — — — — — -�� �/ | | '4--'�' --'/ �������� ' |�— .. . .LF— — —Lj | (N) ROOF LEVEL FLOOR | | PLAN ' IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE WALL LEGEND UffIlt LEVEL WALLS MW LEVEL WALLS __ - __ - __ x | x |{ U | x |/| x | || x | U | U | x ||| || | /| | o / x |�| x '| x | / 1L — — — — — — — — — -�� �/ | | '4--'�' --'/ �������� ' |�— .. . .LF— — —Lj | (N) ROOF LEVEL FLOOR | | PLAN ' IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE WALL LEGEND UffIlt LEVEL WALLS MW LEVEL WALLS IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE WALL LEGEND UffIlt LEVEL WALLS MW LEVEL WALLS 7 LM il Psi (E) FRONT / EAST ELEVATION N Danertslom are to he Fiekt Verfled 72 7 Cella Shake un nom■ nn nn un un un uu o /., _ ■ ■ I.I. Millry , (E) RIGHT / NORTH ELEVATION Nute AN Dunentiws are to be Field Verified M !Im u 7 F.F. _ TP. (E) Wood mom. i O V m m V Q C a�LL� w F- U L /R O W o W U cC � � V OC> ta a�i O Ica Date 8/22/03 L ' C 02063 Sde 1/4' -1'-0' Sheet tMe FRONT RIGHT ELEVATIONS A -11 S ;o o s W U cC � � V OC> ta a�i O Ica Date 8/22/03 L ' C 02063 Sde 1/4' -1'-0' Sheet tMe FRONT RIGHT ELEVATIONS A -11 S uLt 12 /1 -,, U� 35 !Elm ■ m■ ER so on ME M LaLill X �� I i (E) REAR / WEST ELEVATION Note: All Dipp ions are to be Field Verified 12 7� IN 1, 7 F.F. Ty. —_ —__— . . . F.F. Er= --.— —.— . . . . —.— I -- — — - — — - — - — - T.P. (E) LEFT / SOUTH ELEVATION Rite: AD Dirnenslorm are to be Field Verified L 1 .6 IN 33 LU F- Z 4- 4-J Verne 0. V. Project MIN o 0 D— by-. IME MIN IMEME —_ —__— . . . F.F. Er= --.— —.— . . . . —.— I -- — — - — — - — - — - T.P. (E) LEFT / SOUTH ELEVATION Rite: AD Dirnenslorm are to be Field Verified L 1 .6 IN 33 LU F- Z 4- 4-J Verne 0. V. 00 Ti w to ,t O 0 A Dow. 8R2/03 Project a 02063 o 0 D— by-. x 0 00 Ti w to ,t O 0 A Dow. 8R2/03 Project a 02063 s—le: 114•.1 •o• D— by-. SEMM Sheet tftk- (E) REAR LEFT ELEVATIONS A-12 12 3N 7 2E 11 ®III � I 3N �—�ZE y—a 1 �R I I OE �—�—► 3N ®� -- WE ® - PoRON (N) FRONT / EASE ELEVATION t N� All D6ne� are to be Field Verified ' NEW 00ANEY CAP TO MATCH EXISTW 12 7 pp FBI n _wi�i�iniv (N) RIGHT / NORTH ELEVATION YLE AND SHAPE OF CHIMNEY Ml!ST BE F 12 7 F.F. U T.P. ._._._ F.F. -- -.T.P. 3N Recesud Patio KEY NOTES Fm miss MATEmALS 1E HORIZONTAL LAP WING - EGSTWG 1 N HORIZONTAL LAP SIDING - NEW TO MATCH DOSTING 2E TONGUE - AND -GRCIO E FLAT BOARD SDM - COSTING OTONGUE - AND - GROOVE FIAT BOARD SIDING - NEW TO MATCH D=TWG 3N 'S1A E7 COMPOSITION ROOFING TO IMITATE E)OSITNG CEDAR SHAKE ROOF 4E TIGHT BRICK JOINTS AND DEEP RED COLOR - E)W]7NG 4H TIGHT BRICK JOINTS AND DEEP RED COLOR - NEW TO MATCH DISKING OCONCRETE CURB FOOTING - BaSTI NG OCONX7iETE CIM FOOTING - NEW TO HATCH D04TBNG OWOW SHINGLE SIDING - EJOSTDNG OWOOD SINGLE SIDIK- - NEW TO MATCH DISKING ONEW LATTICE ONEW PALM W/ 4X POSTS 8 2X BALUSTERS OWOOD SPINDLE RAILING - E7/STING SIN WOOD SPINDLE RAILING - NEW TO MATCH Dawn NG ® WOOD PANEL - E)OSTI NC ® WOOD PANEL - NEW TO MATCH EXISTBNG I E CLASSICAL BALUSTRADE - EXISTING 1® CLASSICAL BALUSTRADE - NEW TO MATCH DOS TM IMPORTANT IMPORTANT RENOVA�ON NOTE WORKING PRIORMES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE R SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE KEY NOTES FoR nmsni mATmAs HORENWAL LAP SIDING - E)3S7TING / 3N �� 3N 1 N HORMONT/LL LAP SOM - NEW TO MATCH E)aSrnNG 2E TONGUE-AND-GROOVE FIAT BOARD SIDING - FASIIIIG �� 2N TONGUE -AMD- GROOVE FLAT BOARD SIDING - NEW TO MATCH EXLSITING ALI- SHAKE' C04W03T10N ROOFING TO HTATE E)Q4TMG CEDAR SHAKE ROOF 6E �:% 5� O TGfT BRICK JOINTS AND DFID RED COLOR - EJISFFN6 OTIGHT BRICK JOINTS MID DEEP RID COLOR - NEW TO MATCH DaSI TWG — — — — — — — — — — — — — 5 _ CONCRETE CURB CAffi FOOTNG - EXISTW T.P. — .— . —. - -- — — — .— .— . —. —.— .— . —. —.— O CONCRETE C19t8 FOOTIIG - NEW TO MATCH FXSRIING WOOD SFWNGLE SDING-BaSTM 1E O WOOD S MI S M - NEW TO MATCH D)3WM 711 �o 4N 7N NEW LATTICE TN BN ONEW RALRNG W/ 4X POSTS 8 2X BALUSTERS t E O WOAD SPINDLE RAILING - EXISTHIG ...... _ _ ___ _ _ _ WOOD 99VU RALM -NEW TO MATCH EX<4 M ® WOOD PANEL - EXISTING . ® WOOD PANEL - NEW TO MATCH EIaWM rn. • Darr. SE CLASSICAL BALUSTRADE - DOSTBM U u t® CLASS AL BALUSTRADE - KEW TO MATCH EXL4TDNG Grade — — — — — — G.aae IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING RS FOR ALL ASPECTS (N) REAR / WEST ELEVATION OF TFi)S JOB B ARE A AS FOLLOWS: Noce: All Dkn nsiom are to be Reid Vedfed FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT ■ SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT TRRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE (N) LEFT / SOUTH ELEVATION Note AD Dtrneradara arc to be Field Verdled mo�orv� Q � � x m � N. ! l W F- -6 . '1-d c I.J c CIO _o B 2 2 . 3a I : � �aa W U W o > ci a -0W) .d a` aQ�" ow � Date: 8/22/03 PrDje 002063 Dt Iy. SE}M, PD Beet We \ "J REAR LEFT ELEVATIONS A -14 0 a o I; o 5 E W U W o > ci a -0W) .d a` aQ�" ow � Date: 8/22/03 PrDje 002063 Dt Iy. SE}M, PD Beet We \ "J REAR LEFT ELEVATIONS A -14 viz �1 F) 7:12 w I 112 ( \ T � � r� II Vi I I�. E RIDGE�- I l:)z Tsz I I ,I I F I UI � J li (E) GARAGE ROOF PLAN IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE R SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE R WITH LIKE { < I I I I 1 (E) GARAGE FLOOR PLAN la w NOW WALL LEGEND AB dirisiorn are to bs Field VMfled NEW WALLS E USTM WALLS — — — — WALLS TO BE REMOVE r W c LL —erg W H .5 4-J c c D Q) sY W z W o >° W ¢tu r. Dam &122/03 Project • 02063 3dc Dawn by SO4K PD shw dit (F) GARAGE FLOOR ROOF PLAN A -16 0 8 0 8 5 i; W z W o >° W ¢tu r. Dam &122/03 Project • 02063 3dc Dawn by SO4K PD shw dit (F) GARAGE FLOOR ROOF PLAN A -16 TV/ ROOM eFnROOM o �ogr Roots w u HALL F..-- T. MASTER BEDROOM GREAT ROOM TO ENTRY POWDER TO ROOM HOME OFFICE ROOM I I CLOSET GAME LIM m ��a Q uT° _ s n, W Z T C U N v W A CD b � W ¢�v bo a ;,gib G h O Datc B/ZZ/03 P;*C • 02063 Sdr. 114'-I'-(r 0- by-- SDO1 PD Short UtlC A -15 O O O ti � O �F 3 � s s W A CD b � W ¢�v bo a ;,gib G h O Datc B/ZZ/03 P;*C • 02063 Sdr. 114'-I'-(r 0- by-- SDO1 PD Short UtlC A -15 w.m.. (U 2a6 a \ 2630 Ndwva & (E)2M6 (Q2016 —AK6'_� IMPORTANT RENOVATION NOTE WORKING PRIORITIES FOR ALL ASPECTS OF THIS JOB ARE AS FOLLOWS: FIRST - TRY TO PRESERVE IT SECOND - TRY TO REPAIR IT THIRD - REPLACE IT WITH LIKE (11120K (ID 20K <M 6• comma atmmmnm \ (E)2030 wm> wv (E)2630 (E)2630 na.�oK (E) zem .meo. a omit n nor.d =— ------ - - - - -� 2010 20K - ( 2610 (E)F410 C=M WAUS . l[nu'�fttFs I! ll cEe tx zese tto m zeta BEDROOM 4 ErmN Ii E,ete, amo e w 3o3e BEDROOM 5 = a a Ii rm.a pmh E FM)GE STORAGE II lqO p 2m P.— (E) .w.awe gs < �- II y �e - ;;; I ! kO (E) 2630 zm Pp a n (a �I ' I LMNG ROOM amp (q z66e e p ! I p £ II is 3e6s LIVING ROOM �- ow (ML9.0a Rt — tD i66e . COVERED 00 n. r COVERED PORCH o PORCH BEDROOM 2 e (ro sn— w -m—o 71 yiln.Kim.. BATH te• ow COVERED #1 KITCHEN (E) 2660 . COVERED Em BEDROOM 3 PORCH N R PORCH Fq OF 0 M, I rr I 1 : \ (E)2030 wm> wv (E)2630 (E)2630 na.�oK (E) zem .meo. a omit n nor.d =— ------ (N) GUEST HOUSE FLOOR PLAN (E) GUEST HOUSE ROOF PLAN ' ___ _. -- = =r = = =— ------ - - - - -� 2010 20K g ( 2610 (E)F410 C=M WAUS »g — — _ — W.U1S TO BE REMOVED I! ll BEDROOM 4 IF = a a i E FM)GE i BEDROOM S 3< 2m I ;;; n S (E) GUEST HOUSE ROOF PLAN ' 5010 AN dhttatdoEts ale to he Field Verified 2016 20K 2010 20K g ( 2610 (E)F410 C=M WAUS »g — — _ — W.U1S TO BE REMOVED BEDROOM 4 BEDROOM T = a a BEDROOM S 3< 2m ;;; S LIVING ROOM . g BEDROOM 2 e te• ow COVERED (E) 2660 . COVERED PORCH N R PORCH 0 0 s KITCHEN G� BEDROOM c m OF NM (E) 1130 (E) 21L10 (E) 2630 (E) 2630 • -0. r 49-4' (E) GUEST HOUSE FLOOR PLAN AN dhttatdoEts ale to he Field Verified WALL LEGEND M O 0 NEW WA" g C=M WAUS 5 — — _ — W.U1S TO BE REMOVED O M O 0 O g 5 = a a �, a r